Sr. No. Date Name Citations Issues Sections
1 1967-01-11 A & Others vs. WTO (Bom.) (1978) T & P Vol. 11 Jan. 67 Charitable Trust 13(1)(h), 23A of W. T. Act
2 1973-06-18 CIT vs. Mahalakshmi Glass Works (P) Ltd. (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 8 Reference Application 256(1), 2(16) 121
3 1974-03-15 Deb. Sahitya Kuthir (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Cal.) (1983) 3 SOT 450 Industrial Company – Manufacturing 80J(4), 2(7)(d)
4 1974-10-18 A Bombay vs. ITO (Bom.) (1974) T & P Vol. 6 Oct. 18 House Property – Municipal Taxes 23
5 1975-05-21 ITO vs. Salve (N.K.P.) (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 184 Profession – Expenses for Contesting the election allowable 37(1), 28(i)
6 1976-04-24 India Sugars & Refineries Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 167 Deduction – Gross – Net -Dividend option claim 80L, 80 M, 80A, 80AB, 70 (1)
7 1976-11-26 WTO vs. Sona S. Sapatwalla (Mrs.) (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 105 Wealth Tax Assets – Exemption 2(m)(ii)
8 1977-05-28 Trustees of Sabrina Charitable Trust vs. WTO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 262 Charitable Trust – Discrisionary 21A, 13(2)(h), 5(1)(1)
9 1977-08-11 Bhilal Engg. Corpn. Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Nag.) (1997) 63 ITD 223 / (2002) 75 TTJ 505 Depreciation 32
10 1977-09-01 Thirunavukkarasu Chettiar (SL. SP. PL.) vs. ACED (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 178 Estate Duty – Adoption of son 6
11 1977-10-07 Kalavati Pakvasa (Mrs.) vs. ACED (Bom.) (1983) SOT 126 Estate Duty – Valuation of property 5, 36(2)
12 1977-10-28 Birad Kanwar of Udaipur vs. (1983) 3 SOT 230 ITO (Jp.) Income 4, 10(2), 10(19)
13 1977-11-08 Lookmani Readymade Clothes vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 488 Penalty – Registration 139(1), 271(1)(a)
14 1977-12-01 Amar Dye Chem. Ltd. vs. ITO (Born) (1983) 3 SOT 384 Tribunal – Powers – Vires / Capital / Business Expenditure 255, 28, 37, 80J r.w. 19A(3)
15 1977-12-09 Rajshri Productions (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 500 Circular – Assessment – Binding 119
16 1978-01-31 Vayaskara Aryavilasam Oushadasala (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Coch.) (1983) 3 SOT 484 Deduction – Retrenchments Compensation 37(1), 25 FF Industrial Dispute Act
17 1978-02-23 ITO vs. India Type & Rubber Co. Ltd. (Bom) (1983) 3 SOT 92 Appeal – Interest 246 , 214
18 1978-03-23 Nichani (V. N.) vs. WTO (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 200 Exemption – Residential House – Co-owner 5(1)(iv)
19 1978-03-31 S. H. V. Raj Badhar Naidu Chetter vs. WTO (1978) tax 50 (6) 73 Wealth Tax – Cinema Theatre owned – expenses 5(1)(iv)
20 1978-04-24 Bangalore Trading Corpn. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 26 Appeal – Revised Return 139(2), 215
21 1978-04-24 ITO vs. Kosamattam Chitty Fund & Investment (Coch.) (1983) 3 SOT 16 Income – Chitties 4, 28
22 1978-05-29 Orissa Cement Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 79 Priority Industry 80 – I
23 1978-06-29 Globe Trading Co. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 353 Appeal – Registration 246(1)(c), 184 (7)
24 1978-07-29 Geoffrey Manners & Co. Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 40 Company – Directors – 40(c), 40 A(5)(c)
25 1978-10-12 Brahadeeswaram (R.) vs. ACED (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 101 Additional Grounds – Appellate Tribunal – Power 63, 34(1)(c)
26 1978-12-21 Frick India Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 64 Capital or Revenue – Technical know how 37(1)
27 1979-01-31 Nar Hari Dalmia vs. ITO (Delhi) (1984) 7 ITD 463 Income – Interest Income– Clubbing of Income 4, 64
28 1979-02-08 Pelikon Paper Stationery Mart vs. ITO (1984) 7 ITD 346 Firm – Retirement – Dissolution 188
29 1979-02-08 Raj Pottery Works vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 221 (1986) 26 TTJ 311 Firm – Registration Rate applicable 187
30 1979-06-12 Soft Beverages (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 311 / (1983) 3 ITD 686 Deduction 40A(7)
31 1979-07-11 Sri Koda Katla Rice Mill vs. ITO (Hyd) (1979) 8 TTJ 566 Deduction – confiscation of goods 28
32 1979-07-27 Dwarkadas & Co. (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 ITD 303 / (1982) 13 TTJ 107 / 1 SOT 495 Revision – Commissioner, Appeal 263, 246, 214
33 1979-07-30 Mansa Ram and Sons vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 133 Reassessment – Non Disclosure 34, 148
34 1979-07-31 ITO vs. Chadha (G.K.) (Delhi) (1982) 1 SOT 191 Interest on Borrowed Capital 36(1)(iii)
35 1979-08-18 Ranjit Kumar Mullick vs. WTO (Cal.) (1983) 3 SOT 196 Wealth Tax – Deduction Debt owed 2(m)
36 1979-10-01 ITO vs. Vickers Sperry of India (Bom.) 1 SOT 105 (1983) 3 ITD 739 / (1982) Depreciation – Scientific Research, Perquistes, Medical expenses 17, 32, 35 (1)
37 1979-10-31 Modipon Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 328 Development – Rebate – New Industrial Undertaking 33, 80J(i)
38 1979-12-18 Bijoynagar Tea Co. Ltd. vs. ITO (1983) 3 SOT 116 Agricultural Development Allowance 35C
39 1979-12-19 Colaba Central Co-op. Consumers Wholesale and Retail Stores Ltd vs. ITO (Bom.) (1981) 12 TTJ 379 / (1983) 3 SOT 46 Co-operative Society – Deduction 28, 37 (1)
40 1980-03-01 Joseph John vs. ITO (Coch.) (1982) SOT 552 / (1983) 3 ITD 571 Penalty – Concealment 271(1)(c), 274(2) and 139
41 1980-11-10 ITO vs. Sri Ramakrishna Contrs. (Hyd.) (1983) 3 SOT 479 Estimate of Profits – Interest to partners 29, 40(b)
42 1980-11-20 Uttar Gujarat Sahakari Ru Vechan Sangh Ltd. vs. ITO (Ahd.) (1983) 3 SOT 51 Bad Debts 36(1)(vii)
43 1981-01-21 ITO vs. Tata Robins-Fraser Ltd.(Cal.) (1982) 1 SOT 229 Capital Revenue Expenditure 37(1)
44 1981-01-21 Tata Robins-Fraser Ltd. vs. ITO (Cal.) (1982) 1 SOT 229 Business Expenditure – Capital or Revenue expenditure – Technical know-how royalty 37(1)
45 1981-01-24 Sahney Steel & Press Works Ltd. vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1981) 11 TTJ 351 / (1982)1 SOT 316 / (1983) 4 ITD 6 Remission or cessation of liability – Subsidicy 41(1) r.w. 28(iv)
46 1981-01-31 Gulabchand Jhabakh (L.) vs. WTO (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 613 / (1982) 14 TTJ 465 Wealth Tax – Exemption 5(1)(iva)
47 1981-01-31 ITO vs. First Leasing Co. of India (Mad.) (1985) 13 ITD 234 / (1985) 23 TTJ 469 Reassessment – Information – Investment allowance – leasing of machinery 147(b), 32A
48 1981-02-12 Pioneer Match Works vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 331 / (1983) 3 ITD 714 Depreciation – Subsidy 43(1)
49 1981-02-28 Premchand Chaganlal vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1983) 3 ITD 768 / (1982) 1 SOT 27 HUF or Individual – Total partition 4
50 1981-03-04 Jayam (Smt. K.S.) vs. ACED (Mad.) (1983) 3 ITD 804 / (1982) 1 SOT 667 Estate Duty – Notional Portition – Valuation – Interest 39
51 1981-03-17 Biju Patnaik vs. WTO (Delhi) (1982) 12 TTJ 25 / (1982) 1 SOT 623 / (1983) 3 ITD 693 Wealth Tax Rule 1BB – Valuation – Residential House 7(1) / (4)
52 1981-04-10 ITO vs. Sri Krishna Tiles and Potteries P. Ltd. (Mad.) (1982) 13 TTJ 11/ (1982) 1 SOT 305 / (1983) 3 ITD 617 Payments not deductible – Gratuity 40A(7)
53 1981-04-20 IAC vs. Kodak Ltd. (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 517 Amounts not deductible 10(10), 40 A(5)
54 1981-04-20 IAC vs. Kodak Ltd. (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 517 (1986)18 itd 213 Business Disallowance 40A(5)(a)(ii)
55 1981-04-20 IAC vs. Kodak Ltd. (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 517 / (1986) 18 ITD 213 Business Disallowance – Remuneration 40A(5)(a)(ii)
56 1981-04-30 ITO vs. Ranjitmal Chordia (M) (Mad.) 14 TTJ 544 (1982) 1 SOT 78 / (1982) Income from House Property – Annual value – tax levied 23(1)
57 1981-05-15 Mridu Hari Dalmia vs. ITO (1984) 7 ITD 761 1 SOT 367 Salaries – Perquisites fair rental value 17(5)
58 1981-07-18 ITO vs. Sri Sanku Subbalakhmaiah & Sons. (Hyd.) (1982) 1 ITD 402, (1983) 2 SOT 37 Capital or Revenue – Price paid for Shares 4, 37
59 1981-07-20 Mokashi (Dr. J. N.) vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 ITD 774 / (1982) Clubbing of Income 64(1)(ii)
60 1981-08-07 ITO vs. Hindustan Vacuum Glass Ltd. (Delhi) (1982) 1 SOT 396 / (1983) 3 ITD 605 Business Loss – Unabsorbed depreciation 72(2) r.w. 32(2)
61 1981-09-28 ITO vs. Happy Sound Industries (Delhi) (1982) 13 TTJ 348 / (1982) 1 SOT 172 Export Markets Development Allowance 35B(1)(b)
62 1981-10-20 Ram Gopal Neotia vs. ITO (Cal.) (1982) 1 ITD 160, (1983) 2 SOT 561 Penalty 274(2), 271(1)(c)
63 1981-10-24 Chenni Chattiar (C) vs. WTO (Mad.) (1982) 1 ITD 232 / (1984) 14 TTJ 540/1 507 637 Wealth Tax – HUF – Reassessment 20 r.w. 17
64 1981-11-07 Mohan Rao (K.S.). vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1982) 1 SOT 34 / (1983) 4 ITD 1 HUF or Individual –Inheritance by son 4
65 1981-11-26 ITO vs. Southern Roadways (P) Ltd. (Mad) (1983) 3 SOT 54 Capital Gains – Capital Receipts, Route Permit 32(1)(iii), 45, 41(2), 50
66 1981-12-07 ITO vs. C. L. Sadani Family Trust (Cal.) (1982) 1 ITD 223 / (1982) 1 SOT 484 Trust – Beneficiary – Unborn Person 164 (1)
67 1982-01-06 ITO vs. M. Ct. M. Chidambaram Chettiar Foundation (Mad.) (1982) 1 ITD 14 / (1982) 1 SOT 66 / (1982) 14 TTJ 548 Charitable Trust – Accumulation of Income 11
68 1982-01-06 M. Ct. Muthiah Chettiyar Family Trust. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 IT D 14 / 199/(1982) 1 SOT 53 Charitable Trust – Accumulation of Income 11
69 1982-01-16 Arasan Aluminium Industries (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 ITD 10 / (1982) 1 SOT 45 Income – Capital Revenue Receipt – Pre Commencement 4
70 1982-01-22 Wood Craft Products Ltd. vs. ITO (Cal.) (1982) 1 ITD 1 / (1982) 1 SOT 407 Deductions – Religious nature 80 G
71 1982-01-29 Rajendra Kumar Tuli vs. WTO (Bom.) (1982) 1 ITD 213 / (1982) 1 SOT 601 Net Wealth – Debt Owed 2(m)
72 1982-01-29 Shah (N. M.) vs. WTO (Bom.) (1982) 1 ITD 244 / (1982) 1 SOT 573 Wealth Tax – Net Wealth 2(m)
73 1982-02-10 Narayanaswamy (V.) vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 ITD 397 / (1983) 2 SOT 274 Clubbing of Income –Deduction of Bank Interest 64, 80 L
74 1982-02-15 Investment Corporation of India Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 ITD 880 / (1982) 14 TTJ 250 / (1983) 2 SOT 260 Capital Gain on Sale of Shares 48(ii)
75 1982-02-25 Pattan Masthan Khan vs. GTO (Hyd.) (1982) 2 ITD 130 / (1983) 2 SOT 733 Gift Tax – Stamp Duty 18A
76 1982-03-29 ITO vs. Nagpur Zilla Krishi Audhyogik Sahakari Sangh Ltd. (Nag.) (1982) 2 ITD 138 / (1983) 2 SOT 345 Deductions – Income from Co-op. Soc. – Relief 80P(2)
77 1982-04-02 Chadha (R. D.) vs. CIT (Delhi) (1982) 2 ITD 592 / (1983) 2 SOT 77 Exemption – Terminal Benefit 10 (10A) (i)
78 1982-04-02 Sachdev (P. C.) vs. CIT (Delhi) (1983) 2 SOT 77 / (1982) 2 ITD 592 Exemption – Pension 10(10A)(i)
79 1982-04-13 ITO vs. Rajaratna Naranbhai Mills Ltd. (Ahd.) (1982) 1 ITD 1044 / (1983) 2 SOT 144/(1983) 17 TTJ 163 Depreciation – Carry forward 32(2)
80 1982-04-14 Rajen Ramesh Chandra vs. ITO (Ahd.) (1982)1 ITD 791 / (1983) 2 SOT 32 HUF – Individual 4
81 1982-04-23 ITO vs. Krishna Iyer (S.) (Mad.) 2 SOT 298 (1982) 2 ITD 595 / (1983) Clubbing of Income – Transfer 64 (i)(iii)
82 1982-04-23 ITO vs. Subbiah Chettiar (C.) (Mad.) 2 ITD 595 (1983) 2 SOT 298 / (1982) Transfer of Assets 64(1)(iii)
83 1982-04-27 U. P. Tractors vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 381 Appellate – Asst. Commissioner – Powers 251
84 1982-04-30 Rajratha Naranbhai Mills Ltd. (1982) 1 ITD 1044, (1983) 2 SOT 144 Carry forward of unabsorbed depreciation 32(2)
85 1982-05-11 ITO vs. Framji (Smt. S.J.) (Bom.) (1982)1 ITD 390 / (1983) 2 SOT 358 Capital Gain – Sale of Shares in Co-op. Housing Society 80T (b)(i)
86 1982-05-13 Mannalal Nirmal Kumar Soorana vs. ITO (Delhi) (1982) 1 ITD 412 / 14 TTJ 392 / (1983) 2 SOT 631 Capital Assets–Voluntary Disclosure of Income & Wealth Act,1976 2(14) / 45 r.w. 2(47) / 5 / 3/ 8,11,12,16
87 1982-05-24 ITO vs. Sippy Films (Bom.) (1982) 1 ITD 1031 / (1982) 14 TTJ 368 / (1983) 2 SOT 532 Appeal – Draft Order 246 r.w. 144 B
88 1982-05-30 Bela Singh Pabla vs. ITO (Delhi) (1982) 1 ITD 370 / (1983) 2 SOT 410 Assessment – Direction – IAC 144B, 143(3), 147
89 1982-05-30 Shree Arbuda Mills Ltd. vs. ITO (Ahd.) (1983) 3 SOT 311 Merger – Appellate Authority 263
90 1982-06-08 Arvind Mills Ltd. vs. ITO (Ahd.) (1982) 1 ITD 872 / 2 SOT 207 Interest paid to Government – Bonus / Business Expenditure 28(i), 37(1), 220 (2)
91 1982-08-16 Travancore Chemical & Msg. Co. Ltd. vs. ITO (Coch.) (1983) 6 ITD 788 Sur Tax – Deduction 2(5) r.w. 2
92 1982-09-06 Executive Engineer and Administrative Officer, Tamil Nadu Housing Board vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 2 ITD 336, (1983) 2 SOT 506 Interest – Payment to Contractor 201, 201(1A), 194(c)
93 1982-09-17 ITO vs. Sawhney (J.L.) (Delhi) (1982) 2 ITD 207 / (1983) 2 SOT 103 Income from House Property – Income from other sources 22
94 1982-09-17 ITO vs. Sawhney (R.K) (Delhi) (1982) 2 ITD 207/ (1983) 2 SOT 103 House Property Income – Building Merged by Company / Income from other Sources 22
95 1982-09-17 ITO vs. Sunita Chadha (Smt.) (Delhi) 2 SOT 103 (1982) 2 ITD 207 / (1983) Income from House Property 22
96 1982-10-13 IAC vs. Cosmopolitan Trading Corpn. (Jp.) (1985) 14 ITD 327 Method of Accounting – Closing stock – GP 145
97 1982-10-22 ITO vs. Jag Mohan Gupta (All) (1983) 2 SOT 449 / (1983) 3 ITD 1 Rectification, Mistakes – Partners Assessment 155, 154(3), 267
98 1982-10-30 ITO vs. Vinay Bharat Ram (Delhi) (1983) 2 SOT 47 / (1983) 3 ITD 263 HUF – Individual – Gift 4
99 1982-11-03 Apara Textile Traders Ltd. vs. STO (Ahd.) (1982) 2 ITD 600 / (1983) Sur Tax – Surcharge Deposit 2 SOT 603 2(5) r.w.2(i) – Deduction
100 1982-11-04 Allied Chemical Corpn. vs. IAC (Bom.) 3 ITD 418 (1983) 2 SOT 62 / (1983) Appellate Tribunal -– Powers, Dividend, Non-Resident 5(2)(b) w.r. Rule 115
101 1982-12-27 ITO vs. Palaniammal (Smt. P.) (Mad.) (1984) 7 ITD 416 Penalty – Self Assessment 140A(3)
102 1982-12-27 Kulandayan Chettiar (P.V.AL) vs. ITO (Mad.) (1983) 2 SOT 369 / (1983) 3 ITD 426 Double Taxation Agreements – Rate Purpose 90 r.w. 5
103 1983-01-13 M. L. Shukla & Co. vs. ITO (All) (1983) 3 ITD 502 / (1983) 3 SOT 29 Diversion at Source by an Over Riding Charge 4
104 1983-03-16 East Coast Marine Products (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1983) 4 ITD 72 Revision – Direction of IAC / Commission 263
105 1983-03-16 ITO vs. Bohra Film Finance (Jp.) (1983) 4 ITD 247 Assessment – Time Limit / Penalty / Return Allowance 153(1)(b) / 271(1)(c) / 139(4) r.w. 153(1)
106 1983-04-04 ITO vs. Peethambari Devi (Smt.) (Mad.) (1983) 4 ITD 557 Capital or Revenue Receipt – Subsidy 4, 28
107 1983-04-15 Hansalaya Properties vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 4 ITD 475 Business Income / Capital Gain – Conversion into stock in trade – enchance cost 28(i) / 254 (1)
108 1983-04-29 Shri Pansara-kan Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. vs. ITO (Pune) (1983) 5 ITD 449 Business Expenditure / Diversion 37(1), 4
109 1983-04-30 ITO vs. Shivaji Park Gymkhana(Bom.) (1983) 4 ITD 462 Assessment – Multicity – Curable defects 144 B
110 1983-05-09 Highway Construction Co. (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (1983) 4 ITD 545 Assessment Order – Validity – Determination of Tax 143 (3)(a) r.w. 292 B
111 1983-05-09 WTO vs. Sheth (C. J. ) (Bom.) (1983) 4 ITD 706 Wealth Tax – Valuation of Assets – Unquoted Equity shares / Advance Tax Liability 7
112 1983-05-16 WTO vs. Narendra Kumar Gupta (Delhi) (1983) 4 ITD 694 Wealth Tax – Asset / Valuation 2(e), 7(2) r.w. rules 2C & 9B
113 1983-08-05 Eastern Bulk Services vs. ITO ) (Delhi (1983) 5 ITD 471 Export Market Development Allowance / Method of Accounting / Appeal – Protective Assessment 35B / 145 / 246
114 1983-08-21 Sivakami Finance Pvt. Ltd. Etc vs. ITO (Mad.) (1984) 18 TTJ 413 Tax Deduction at Source Debit – Interest 194, 221
115 1983-09-14 ITO vs. Bharath Skin Corpn. (Mad.) (1983) 6 ITD 320 / (1984) 18 TTJ 408 / (1984) 19 TTJ 596 Export Markets Development 35B
116 1983-10-10 ITO vs. Mohanasundaram (C.V.) (Mad.) (1983) 6 ITD 769 (1984) 2- TTJ 566 Assessment – Draft Assessment Order – Partner – Time limit 144B, 153
117 1983-10-10 ITO vs. Veerannah Chettiar (K. S.) (1983) 6 ITD 769 Limitation – Draft Assessment Order 144B
118 1983-10-13 American Express International Banking Corpn. vs. IAC (Bom.) (1983) 6 ITD 373 / (1984) 18 TTJ 218 Method of Accounting 145
119 1983-10-14 ITO vs. Vittal Bhat (Dr. P.) (Bang.) (1983) 6 ITD 560 / (1984) 20 TTJ 507 Investment Allowance 32A
120 1983-10-20 TO vs. Hydle Constructions (P) Ltd. (Delhi) (1984) 20 TTJ 518 6 ITD 575 Manufacturer – Industrial Undertaking 80J, 2(a)(c) 80HH
121 1983-10-21 ITO vs. Lachmandas Raghunath Das Parihar (Jp) (1983) 6 ITD 474 / (1984) 20 TTJ 52 Firm – Registered Return Interest 139(8)(a)
122 1983-11-25 ITO vs. Bajaj Auto Ltd. (Bom.) (1984) 8 ITD 296 / (1984) 19 TTJ 198 / (1984) 20 TTJ 551 Income Perquisite 40(c), 40(A)(5)
123 1983-11-29 Irani. (Dr. D. A.) vs. ITO (Bom) (1984) 7 ITD 160 / (1984) 18 TTJ 402 Capital Gain – Tenancy Right 45
124 1984-01-02 ITO vs. Kothari Ltd. (Mad.) (1984) 7 ITD 431 Guest House Expenses 37(4)
125 1984-01-11 Venugopal Naidu (M. S.) vs. ITO (Mad.) (1985) 14 ITD 295 Penalty – Return – Reassessment 271(1)(a) , 148
126 1984-02-08 ITO vs. Kirloskar (S.R.) (Pune) (1984) 8 ITD 288 / (1984) 20 TTJ 361 HUF – Property qua son – Hindu Succession Act 4 r.w. 8
127 1984-02-08 WTO vs. Kirloskar (S.R.) (Pune) (1984) 8 ITD 288 / (1984) 20 TTJ 36114 TTJ 465 HUF 4 r.w. 8
128 1984-03-24 State Bank of Travancore Employees Union vs. WTO (Mad.) (1984) 8 ITD 529 / (1985) 21 TTJ 214 Wealth Tax – Individual 3
129 1984-03-24 Sundaram Finance Ltd. vs. IAC (Mad.) (1984) 7 ITD 845 / (1984) 18 TTJ 348 / (1984) 20 TTJ 582 Business Expenditure – Travelling 37(3) Rule 6 D
130 1984-03-31 Thirumagal Finance Pvt. Ltd. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1984) 18 TTJ 413 TDS 194A
131 1984-03-31 Sardarilal vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1982) 1 SOT 27 / (1982) 3 ITD 768 HUF 4
132 1984-04-06 Deo (R.K.) vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1984) 9 ITD 274 / (1985) 21 TTJ 343 Income from House Property 27(ii)
133 1984-04-18 Kapri International (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1984) 8 ITD 820 Deductions – New Industrial undertakings – Manufacture of goods 80J
134 1984-07-31 French Dyes & Chemicals (I) Pvt. Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1985) 21 TTJ 412 Capital Gain – Long Term 52(2)
135 1984-07-31 ITO vs. French Dyes & Chemicals (I) (P.) Ltd. (Bom.) (1984) 10 ITD 240 / (1985) 21 TTJ 412 Business Expenditure – secret commission 37(1)
136 1984-09-08 Ananthakrishna (B.) vs. ITO (Coch.) (1984) 10 ITD 748 Income – Surrender of earned leave 4
137 1984-09-22 Shri Someshwar Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. & Others vs. ITO (Pune) (1985) 11 ITD 335 / (1985) 21 TTJ 369 Income – Accrual Deposit –Sellers of Commodity 4, 5
138 1984-09-26 Raghunandan (M.) vs. ITO (Mad.) (1985) 11 ITD 298 Income from House Property 22
139 1984-10-29 Excel Productions vs. ITO (Coch.) (1985) 11 ITD 459 Business Income – Interest Income 28(i)
140 1984-10-31 ITO vs. Bharat H. Patel (Bom.) (1985) 12 ITD 663 Salary – Standard deduction 16(i)
141 1984-11-17 CWT vs. Razia Begum (Smt.) (Delhi) (1985) 11 ITD 677 Reference – Question of Law Rule 1BB 27 (1)
142 1984-11-28 ITO vs. Chopra (Lt. Col. G. R.) (Delhi) (1985) 11 ITD 662 Salaries – Standard deduction 16(i)
143 1984-11-30 Indo Asian Switchgears (P) Ltd. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1985) 12 ITD 65 / (1985) 21 TTJ 166 Business Income 28(i)
144 1984-12-19 ITO vs. Maleh Narasimhaiah Setty (Hyd.) (1985) 12 ITD 55 Salaries – Standard deduction 16(i)
145 1985-01-29 CIT vs. Highway Construction Co. (P) Ltd (Cal.) (1986) 15 ITD 66 Reference – Question of Law 256
146 1985-01-31 ITO vs. Bisereli (I) (P) Ltd. (Bom.) (1985) 12 ITD 116 Business Expenditure – guarantee commission 31(1)
147 1985-01-31 National Thermal Power Corpn. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1985) 12 ITD 99 / (2000)68 TTJ 508 Additional Grounds – Powers of ITAT 254
148 1985-02-23 IAC vs. Goodricke Group Ltd. (Cal.) (1985) 12 ITD 1 / (1985) 22 TTJ 394 Non Resident – Deduction of Head Office Expenditure 44C
149 1985-02-26 ITO vs. Vijayalaxmi N. Mafatlal (Smt.) (Bom.) (1985) 12 ITD 12 Business Income – Share Income from Firm – Expenses allowable 2(13), 37(1)
150 1985-03-28 WTO vs. Niranjan Narottam (Individual) (Ahd.) (1985) 14 ITD 27 / (1985)23 TTJ 564 Wealth Tax – Valuation – Self – Occupied Residential house 7(4)
151 1985-04-08 WTO vs. Shashikant K. Doshi (Pune) (1985) 22 TTJ 13 Wealth Tax – Exemption 5(1)(iv)
152 1985-04-30 ITO vs. Poyilakkada Fishers (P) Ltd. (Coch.) (1985) 14 ITD 224 (1986) 25 TTJ 341 Accounting – Method of Account 145(1)
153 1985-05-01 ITO vs. General’s New Tread (Mad.) (1985) 13 ITD 460 Investment Allowance – Retreaded tyre 32A
154 1985-06-11 Gitaben Hasmukhlal Shah (Miss) vs. WTO (Ahd.) (1985) 14 ITD 77 / (1986) 24 TTJ 190 Wealth Tax Valuation 4(1)(b), 4(2) & 7
155 1985-06-28 Des Raj Nagpal vs. ITO (Delhi) (1985) 13 ITD 800 Capital Gain – Long term – Short term 54, 2(42A)
156 1985-06-30 Rohiniben Trust vs. ITO (Bom.) (1985) 13 ITD 830 Capital Gain 45
157 1985-07-01 Smt. Gomti Devi Banarsidas Vaid Charitable Trust vs. ITO (All.) (1985) 13 ITD 729 23 TTJ 270 Appellate Tribunal – Rectification of Mistakes – Accounting methods 254, 145
158 1985-07-12 ITO vs. J. K. Synthetics Ltd. (Delhi) (1982) 1 SOT 415 Deductions – Profits & Gains of priority industry 80-I r.w. 80B, 33(b)(B)(i)
159 1985-07-30 ITO vs. India Rubber & Plastic Co. (Bom.) (1986) 15 ITD 1 Return 139(4) Penalty 271(1)(a)
160 1985-08-02 WTO vs. Seth Sudhir Kumar Modi (Delhi) (1986) 24 TTJ 289 Wealth Tax – Valuation 7(1)
161 1985-08-02 WTO vs. Seth Sudhir Kumar Modi (Delhi) (1985) 14 ITD 194 / (1986)24 TTJ (Delhi) 289 Wealth Tax – Rule 1D – Valuation of Asset – Shares– Firm – partner 7, Rule 10
162 1985-08-05 ITO vs. G. J. Engg. Pvt. Ltd. (Bom.) (1985) 23 TTJ 132 Interest on Current Accounts 40A(B)
163 1985-08-05 Kaloomal Shorimal Sachdev Rangwalla (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1985) 14 ITD 248 / (1985) 23 TTJ 132 Disallowance – Interest to Directors – current account – Deposit – Loan 40A(8)
164 1985-11-26 Jeewan Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1986) 15 ITD 14 / (1986) 24 TTJ 372 Deductions – Dividend – Gross or Net 80M r.w. 80AA
165 1985-12-13 Rajendra Ratilal vs. WTO (Bom.) (1986) 15 ITD 61 / (1986) 24 TTJ 392 Wealth Tax – Exemptions 5(1)(xxxii)
166 1986-01-09 Estate of Late P. G. Mehta vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) ACED (Bom.) (1986) 16 ITD 128 / (1986) 26 TTJ 1 Estate Duty – Aggregation of Property 34(1)(c) r.w. 39(1)
167 1986-01-10 WTO vs. Gopichand (Jp.) (1986) 16 ITD 142 / (1986) 24 TTJ 541 Wealth Tax – Exemptions – Residential House 5(1)(iv)
168 1986-01-13 WTO vs. Shyam Mohan Rawat (Jp.) (1986) 15 ITD 96 / (1986) 25 TTJ 61 Wealth tax – Valuation of assets – Stock 253 r.w. 27, 143, 47(ii)
169 1986-01-21 Gaur Hari Singhania (Dr.) vs. ITO (Bom.) (1986) 16 ITD 1 Capital Gain – Firm – 45
170 1986-01-27 ITO vs. Mathur (S.S.) (Bom.) (1986) 16 ITD 9 Salaries – Perquisites 17(2)(iii)(c) r.w. 10(16)
171 1986-01-29 Mettur Chemical and Industrial Corpn. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 265 / (1983) 3 ITD 612 Remuneration – Commission 40(c)
172 1986-01-29 Rex Cinema Co-owners vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 455 / (1983)3 ITD 633 Assessment – Procedural 144B
173 1986-01-29 Mettur Chemical and Industrial Corpn. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 265 / (1983) 3 ITD 612 Remuneration – Commission 40(c)
174 1986-02-25 ITO vs. Panchganga Sahakari Pani Purvatha Mandali Ltd. (Pune) (1986) 16 ITD 183 / (1986) 25 TTJ 114 Deductions – Supply of water 80P(2)(a)(vi)
175 1986-04-18 Rajapalayam Mills Ltd. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1986) 18 ITD 114 Depreciation – Allowance 32
176 1986-05-13 Sushilaben A. Mafatlal (Smt.) vs. WTO (Bom.) (1986) 18 ITD 189 / (1986) 26 TTJ 67 Wealth Tax – Assets 2(e)(2)(ii)
177 1986-05-30 Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1986) 18 ITD 226(1986) 26 TTJ 190 Disallowance Interest 40 A(8)
178 1986-05-30 Pati Durga Cold Storage vs. ITO(Cal.) (1986) 18 ITD 132 Investment Allowance– Cold storage 32A(2)(b)
179 1986-06-25 WTO vs. Chettiappa Chettliar (S. V.) (Mad.) (1986) 18 ITD 252 / (1986) 26 TTJ 167 Memorandum Wealth Tax – Valuation of shares, Restriction on 7 r.w. 1D
180 1986-10-08 A. P. Paper Mills Ltd. vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1988) 27 ITD 44 Depreciation – Permissive Possession 32 (1)
181 1987-03-06 Saraya Sugar Mills (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (All.) (1985) 13 ITD163 / (1985)23 TTJ 196 Assessment – Validity – Jurisdiction 143(3) r.w. 144B, 125A
182 1987-04-23 Detective Devices (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1987) 22 ITD 9 / (1988) 30 TTJ 327 Appellate Tribunal – Powers – Additional Grounds / Transfer / Business Income – Deposit – Company / Depreciation 254 / 2(47) / 28(i) / 32
183 1987-07-06 Siemens Atkiengsellschaft vs. ITO (Bom.) (1987) 22 ITD 87 Double Taxation Agreements Royalties – Business expenditure 37(1), 90 r.w. 2, 9(1)
184 1987-07-17 National Thermal Power vs. AC (Delhi) (1988) 24 ITD 1 Income from Other Sources – Deduction 4 / 56 / 57(ii)
185 1987-09-16 Dhanwatay (Smt. S. V.) vs. WTO (Nag.) (1989) 28 ITD 135 / (1989)33 TTJ 136, (1983) 2 SOT 31 Valuation officer – Reference/Individual 16A r.w. 3A, 3
186 1987-09-23 Craig Harvey (H. F.) vs. ITO (Mad.) (1988) 25 ITD 1 Capital Gains 55(2)(i) r.w. 49(2)
187 1987-09-23 H. F. Craig Harvey vs. ITO (Mad.) (1988) 25 ITD 1 (1988) 30 TTJ 399 Capital Gain – Cost of acquisition – Tribunal Additional Ground 48, 49(2), 55(2), 252
188 1987-11-09 Poysha Industrial Co. Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 206 / (1983)4 ITD 41 Business Expenditure –Fluctuation Loss 37(1)
189 1987-12-02 Hindustan Welfare Trust vs. ITO (Cal.) (1988) 26 ITD 1 11(1A), 2(14) Charitable or religious Trust – Exemption – Fixed Deposit – Capital Asset 11(1A), 2(14)
190 1987-12-22 ITO vs. H. F. Craig Harvey (Mad.) (1988) 30 TTJ 399 Cost of acquisitions of shares- capital gains 55(2)(i) r.w.s 49(2)
191 1988-01-04 Samir Diamonds Exports (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1988) 25 ITD 73 (1988) 30 ITR 561 Export Markets Development Allowance –Interest on Export packing credit – precedent 35B(1)(b)(viii)
192 1988-01-08 Ranbir Raj Kapoor vs. ITO (Bom.) (1988) 25 ITD 56 / (1988) 30 TTJ 650 Hundi 69D
193 1988-01-29 Rajeswari Export House vs. ITO (Coch.) (1988) 25 ITD 379 Reference given effect to High Court 260(1) r.w. 274(2)
194 1988-02-19 WTO vs. Anik Pal Chowdhury (Cal.) (1988) 25 ITD 287 / (1988) 31 TTJ 230 Wealth Tax – Rule 1D –Valuation of Assets 7(1) r.w. 1D of W.T. Act
195 1988-03-25 Gedore Tools (India) (P) Ltd. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1988) 25 ITD 193 Deductions – New Industrial 80J
196 1989-02-14 Man Mohan Singh S. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1989) 35 TTJ 336 Concealment – Penalty – quantum set-a-side 271(1)(c), 273 (a)
197 1989-02-18 Kishan Chand Jain vs. ITO (Delhi) (1989) 34 TTJ 566 Reassessment 147(a)
198 1989-02-18 Munia Devi Jain (Smt.) vs. ITO (Delhi) (1989) 29 ITD 36 / (1989) 34 TTJ 566 Reassessment – Non disclosure of primary facts – Tribunal – powers to change limit 147(a), 147(b), 153(1)
199 1989-03-09 ITO vs. Chandra Kant Trust (Cal.) (1989) 35 TTJ 32 Trust – Shares of Beneficiaries 164(1)
200 1989-03-09 ITO vs. Shri Krishna Bhandar (Cal.) (1989) 35 TTJ 32 Trust – Shares of Beneficiaries 164(1)
201 1989-03-09 ITO vs. Shri Krishna Bhandar Trust (Cal.) (1989) 29 ITD 15 / (1989) 35 TTJ 32 Trust – Beneficiary – Individual 4(d)
202 1989-04-05 Samaj Kalyan Parishad vs. ITO (Delhi) (1989) 30 ITD 1 / (1989) 34 ITR 460 Charitable or religious Trust – Activity of Profit 11
203 1989-04-10 Indo Java & Co. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1989) 30 ITD 161 / (1989) 35 TTJ 111 Tribunal – Powers – Grounds 254 r.w 11 of the ITAT Rules
204 1989-04-20 Jhalani Tools (I) (P.) Ltd. vs. CIT (Delhi) (1989) 31 ITD 81 Appellate Tribunal Special Bench – Reference 256 (1) r.w. 40
205 1989-06-02 ITO vs. Dwarika Prasad Trust (Mrs.) (Delhi) (1989) 34 TTJ 381 Charitable Trust 11
206 1989-06-08 Daks Copy Services (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1989) 30 ITD 223 / (1989) 34 TTJ 604 Investment – Allowance is allowable on Xerox and Photo Copying Machine 32A, 255
207 1989-06-08 Dayakar (P.) vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1995) 53 ITD 25 Salaries – Exemption – conveyance – Development Officer allowance 10(14)
208 1989-07-24 ITO vs. Shri Chaman Prakash & Sons (Delhi) (1989) 31 ITD 105 HUF 4
209 1989-07-24 ITO vs. Chaman Prakash & Sons (Delhi) (1990) 36 TTJ 651(1989) 31 ITD 105 HUF – Partial Partition Income from Firm – HUF or Individual 2(36), 4, 171
210 1989-07-31 Associated Agricultural Development Foundation vs. ITO (Delhi) (1989) 31 ITD 29 Income – Assessable 2(24)
211 1989-08-17 Babu Lal Grand Sons Family Trust vs. ITO (Delhi) (1989) 31 ITD 52 Revision 263
212 1989-09-04 IAC vs. Reinz Dichtungs GmbH (Delhi) (1989) 31 ITD 67 Appellate Tribunal – Order 254
213 1989-09-14 Mohanlal Hargovinddas vs. IAC (Bom.) (1989) 31 ITD 97 / (1989) 35 TTJ 340 Business Expenditure – Good will 37(1)
214 1989-10-16 ITO vs. Abbott Laboratories (P) Ltd. (Bom.) (1989) 31 ITD 183 Disallowance – Companies 40A(5)(6)(1)
215 1989-10-31 Century Iron & Steel Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1989) 31 ITD 117 / (1990) 37 TTJ 43 Deductions – New Industrial undertakings 80HH r.w. 80AB
216 1990-01-01 Nagarjun Steels Ltd. vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1982) 1 SOT 355 / (1983) 3 ITD 796 Income from other sources – Chargeability 56
217 1990-01-04 Shervani Sugar Syndicate Ltd. vs. ITO (All.) (1990) 33 ITD 1 Rectification of mistake Method of Accounting 145(1), 254
218 1990-04-30 Duncans Agro Industries Ltd. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1990) 33 ITD 61 / (1990) 37 TTJ 480 Acquisition of Immovable Properties – Initiation of Properties – Initiation of 269C
219 1990-05-03 ITO vs. Central Wines (Hyd.) (1990) 34 ITD 17 Business Expenditure – Year of deduction 37(1)
220 1990-05-21 K. C. P. Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Hyd.) (1990) 34 ITD 1 Revision 263
221 1990-06-26 K. C. P. Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Hyd.) (1990) 34 ITD 50 Business Expenditure – provision for liquidated damages 37(1)
222 1990-06-26 K. C. P. Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Hyd.) (1990) 34 ITD 66 Business Expenditure – Demand notice – Central excise 37(1)
223 1990-06-27 Sardar Harbans Singh vs. ACED (Hyd.) (1990) 34 ITD 82 Appellate Tribunal – Rectification of Mistake – Estate duty, Insurance money 61
224 1990-07-23 ITO vs. J. K. K. Textile Processing Mills (Mad.) (1990) 38 TTJ 178 Investment Allowance – Manufacture 80J
225 1990-12-10 Rishi Roop Chemical Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1991) 36 ITD 35 / (1991) 39 ITD 660 Deductions 43B
226 1991-03-08 ITO vs. Andhra Pradesh Paper Mills Ltd. (Hyd.) (1991) 38 ITD 1 / (1991) 41 TTJ 89 Business Expenditure 37(1)
227 1991-03-21 Colonisers vs. Asstt. CIT (Hyd.) (1992) 41 ITD 57 / (1992) 45 TTJ 114 Appellate Tribunal – Powers – Violation of Natural Justice void ab initio 254 r.w. 68
228 1991-03-26 K. C. P. Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Hyd.) (1991) 38 ITD 15 Deductions – Scientific research 35(2)
229 1991-07-01 ITO vs. Manini Niranjanbhai (Smt.) (Ahd.) (1991) 39 ITD 73 Rectification of mistake –Binding nature of jurisdiction High Court 154
230 1991-09-24 Mohammed Omer Family Trust vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1992) 40 ITD 1 / (1991) 41 TTJ 459 Trust – AOP Business Expenditure 4 r.w. 161(1A), 161(1A), 37(1)
231 1991-09-27 Dy. CIT vs. Shashi Kapur (Delhi) (1991) 39 ITD 47 / (1991) 41 TTJ 549 Wealth Tax – Valuation of assets – Interest of partner in firm 7
232 1991-09-27 Dy. CIT vs. Vinod S. Kapur (Delhi) (1991) 39 ITD 47 / (1991) 41 TTJ 549 Wealth Tax – Valuation of assets – Interest of partner in firm 7
233 1991-09-30 Manaktala Chemicals (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1991) 39 ITD 35 / (1991) 41 TTJ 447 Disallowance – Interest 40A(8)
234 1991-09-30 Pushpam (Mrs. S.) vs. ACED (Delhi) (1991) 39 ITD 26 / (1991) 41 TTJ 560 Estate Duty – Share in HUF 6 of E. D. Act
235 1991-10-07 Shri Chhatrapati Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Pune) (1992) 40 ITD 117 / (1992) 43 TTJ 90 (1992) 198 ITR 78 (AT) Business Income – Sugar Industry 4, 28(i)
236 1991-10-11 IAC vs. Mitsui & Co. Ltd. (Delhi) (1991) 39 ITD 59 / (1991) 41 TTJ 547 Income – Deemed to accrue license office – permanent establishment 9
237 1991-10-11 Mitsui & Co. Ltd. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1991) 41 TTJ 547 & 569 Income – Deemed 9
238 1991-11-25 WTO vs. Krishna Murthy (R.) (Hyd.) “(1992) 40 ITD 89 / (1992) 42 TTJ 627 (1992) 1981 ITR 131 (AT)” Wealth Tax – Hindu Undivided Family – Partition 20 r.w. 171
239 1991-12-27 A. K. Jain & Bros. (HUF) vs. ITO (Delhi) (1992) 40 ITD 100 / (1992) 42 TTJ 353 Advance Tax – Interest – Refunds 214, 221, 232 243 r.w. 237, 244 & 240
240 1991-12-27 ITO vs. Raveendra Engg. Construction Co. (Coch.) (1992) 40 ITD 63 / (1992) ) 43 TTJ 1 Firm – Registration 184 r.w. 185
241 1992-01-06 Dy. CIT vs. Shree Lalit Fabrics (P.) Ltd. (Chd.) (1992) 41 ITD 119 Investment Allowance – Manufacture / Tribunal – Special Bench 32A / 255 (3)
242 1992-01-10 ITO vs. V. R. V. & Company (Mad.) (1992) 41 ITD 8 Firm – Interest – Salary – Partners – Representation capacity 40(b)
243 1992-01-30 Vedachala Mudaliar (C.) vs. ITO) (Mad.) (1992) 41 ITD 1 Capital Gain – Immovable property – Date of transfer 45 r.w. 2(47) & 147
244 1992-03-04 Chemosyn (P) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1992) 42 ITD 1 / (1992) 42 TTJ 403 Business Expenditure Advertisement – Publicity Samples 37 (3A) / 37 (3B)
245 1992-03-04 ITO vs. Chemosyn (P.) (Ltd.) (Bom.) 42 TTJ 403 (1992) 42 ITD 1 / (1992) Advertisement Expenditure 37 (3A) / 37 (3B)
246 1992-03-24 R. M. Enterprises vs. ITO (Bom.) (1992) 42 ITD 23 / (1992) 43 TTJ 165 Deductions – New Industrial undertakings – Article or thing 80-I
247 1992-03-30 ITO vs. Ramkrishna Bajaj (Bom.) 43 TTJ 400 (1992) 41 ITD 161 / (1992) Appellate Tribunal – Special Bench / Capital Gains 255(3) 45, 185
248 1992-09-12 Graphite Vicarb India Ltd. vs. ITO (Cal.) (1992) 43 ITD 28 DTAA – Deduction at source 195(2) r.w. 9(1)(vi)
249 1992-10-09 Jaipuria (R. K.) vs. WTO (Delhi) (1992) 45 ITD 153 Wealth Tax – Valuation of Immovable 68 Taxman 191 (Mag.)Properties 7
250 1992-10-26 Sutlej Cotton Mills Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Cal.) (1993) 45 ITD 22 / (1993 46 TTJ 310 Appellate Tribunal / Method of Accounting / Book Profits 255/145/ 115J
251 1992-12-09 Surana Steels (P.) Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Hyd.) (1993) 45 ITD 1 / (1993) 46 TTJ 458(1993) 201 ITR 1 (AT) Book Profits – Revision 115J r.w. 263
252 1993-03-18 Oriental Hotels Ltd. vs. IAC (Mad.) (1993) 46 ITD 1 / (1993) 46 TTJ 685 Depreciation – Development Rebae – Hotel 32(i), (ii), 33(1)(b)(B)(ii) 80J(8)
253 1994-01-28 Indian Communication Network (P) Ltd. vs. IAC (Delhi) (1994) 49 ITD 56 / (1994) 48 TTJ 604 Disallowance – Custom Duty Exim duty, Valuation of Assets 43B
254 1994-02-02 Food Specialities Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1994) 48 TTJ 621 Method of Accounting 37(1), 37(3A), 43B & 45
255 1994-02-02 ITO vs. Food Specialities Ltd. (Delhi) (1994) 49 ITD 21 / (1994) 48 TTJ 621 (1984) 206 ITR 119 (AT) Disallowance – Excise duty Valuation of Stock – accounts 43B, 145
256 1994-02-16 Devendra Kumar Jain vs. Asstt. CWT (Delhi) (2000) 67 TTJ 1 Wealth Tax – Asset – Shares 2(e)
257 1994-04-25 WTO vs. Gulabchand Jhabakh (L.) (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 613 / (1982) Wealth Tax Exemption 5(1)(iva)
258 1994-07-25 International Research Park Laboratories Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Delhi) (1994) 50 ITD 37 / (1994) (1995) 212 ITR (AT) Exports – Total turnover 50 TTJ 661 80 HHC, 119 circular – Tribunal
259 1994-12-20 WTO vs. Mistry (K. M.) (Bom.) (1995) 52 ITD 39 / (1995) 51 TTJ 678 Wealth Tax – Net Wealth– Assets belonging to assessee 2(m)
260 1994-12-26 R. Jagadish Chandran (Ind.) vs. IAC (Mad.) (1995) 53 ITD 15 (1995) 214 ITR (AT) Cost of acquisition – Capital Gain – Bonus Shares 48, 45, 49, 55
261 1995-03-15 WTO vs. Shaileshchandra D. Shah & Ors. (Ahd.) (1995) 83 Taxman 352/(1995) 52 TTJ 354 House – Partners – House Property – Exemption 5(1)(iv)
262 1995-03-15 WTO vs. Shri Girishchandra Dahyabhai Family Trust (Ahd.) (1995) 52 TTJ 354 House – Partners –House Property – Exemption 5(1)(iv)
263 1995-04-08 Karia (N. R.) & (B.R.) vs. WTO(Pune) (1985) 13 ITD 545 Wealth Tax – Exemption – House belonging to assessee – Partner entitled to exemption 5(1)(iv)
264 1995-09-15 Cadell Wvg. Mills Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Bom.) (1995) 55 ITD 137 / (1995) 53 TTJ 538 (1996) 217 ITR 51 (11) Casual & Non-recurring receipts / Capital Gain 10(3) r.w. 45 / 45 r.w.2(47)
265 1995-12-30 IAC vs. Bajaj Tempo Ltd. (Pune) (1996) 57 ITD 1 / (1996) 55 TTJ 43 Business Expenditure – Royalty – Capital and Revenue 37(1)
266 1996-02-05 B. S. Malhotra (HUF) vs. Dy. CIT (Pune) (1996) 55 TTJ 493 Reassessment – Material particulars – Wealth Tax Return 147(a)
267 1996-02-05 Baldevraj Sitaram Malhotra (HUF) vs. ITO (Pune) (1996) 58 ITD 35 / (1996) 55 TTJ 493 Reassessment 147(a)
268 1996-02-05 B. S. Malhotra (HUF) vs. Dy. CIT (Pune) (1996) 55 TTJ 493 Reassessment 147(a)
269 1996-02-08 Dy. CIT vs. Kicha Sugar Co. Ltd.(Delhi) (1996) 57 ITD 11 / (1996)55 TTJ 4 Bonus – Customary – Business Expenditure 37 (1), 36 (1)(ii),
270 1996-04-30 Asstt. CIT vs. Gayatri Traders (Hyd.) 56 TTJ 303 (1996) 58 ITD 121 / (1996) Penalty – Failure to Get Accounts Audited 271B r.w. 44AB
271 1996-05-21 ITO vs. Purshottam Lal Roongata Family Welfare Trust (Jp.) (1996) 58 ITD 19 / (1996) 56 TTJ 159 Income from House Property – Deductions 24
272 1996-07-23 Lenses Centre vs. ITO (Hyd.) (1997) 60 ITD 11 / (1997) 57 TTJ 359 Accounting – Valuation of Closing Stock 145
273 1996-12-20 Asstt. CIT vs. Srinivasulu (M.) (Hyd.) 59 TTJ 393 (1997) 62 ITD 159 / (1997) Assessment –Prima facie adjustment 143(1)(a)
274 1997-04-21 Dy. CIT vs. Nagarjuna Investment Trust Ltd. (Hyd.) (1998) 65 ITD 17 / (1998) 62 TTJ 33 Income – Accrual – Method of Accounts 5 r.w. 145
275 1997-07-08 Rahulkumar Bajaj vs. ITO (Nag.) (1998) 64 ITD 73 / (1999) 64 TTJ 182 Reassessment – Information/ Rectification of mistakes 147 (b) / 254
276 1997-08-29 Shree Leasing & Industrial Finance Co. Ltd. vs. ITO (Delhi) (1998) 62 TTJ 448 Appellate Tribunal Powers 252 – 254
277 1998-05-26 Asstt. CIT vs. Soni Photo Films (P.) Ltd. (Delhi) (1998) 67 ITD 81 / (1999) 64 TTJ 682 (2000) 245 ITR (AT) 11 Appellate Tribunal – Additional Grounds / Investment Allowance 254 / 32A
278 1998-12-28 Rahulkumar Bajaj vs. ITO (Nag.) (1999) 69 ITD 1 / (1999) 64 TTJ 200 Appellate Tribunal – Powers 254
279 1999-01-04 Asstt. CGT vs. Jagan Nath Sayal (Delhi) (2000) 72 ITD 1 Wealth Tax – Asset – Shares 2(e)
280 1999-01-14 Jagan Nath Sayal vs. Asstt. CGT (Delhi) (2000) 72 ITD 1 / (2000)67 TTJ 1 Wealth Tax – Valuation of Assests – Membership of Stock Exchange 2(e), 7 r.w. Sch. III
281 1999-02-25 J. C. Chandiok vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (1999) 69 ITD 75 / (1999) 64 TTJ 1 Casual and Non-recurring Receipts – Tenancy Right Act, 1958 10(3) r.w. secs. 2 & 5 of the Delhi Rent Control
282 1999-03-09 Lakhanpal National Ltd. vs. ITO (Ahd.) (1999) 69 ITD 9 / (1999) 64 TTJ 128 (1999) 239 ITR (AT) 27 Depreciation – Allowance / Investment Allowance 32 / 32A r.w. 43A(1)
283 1999-06-25 Petroleum India International vs. Dy. CIT (Mum.) (1999) 71 ITD 31 / (1999) 65 TTJ 671 (2000) 241 ITR (AT) 43 (2000) 241 ITR (AT) 43 Deduction – Royalties Foreign Enterprise 80-O
284 1999-08-09 Gulati Saree centre vs. Asstt. CIT (Chd.) (1999) 71 ITD 73 / (2000) 66 TTJ 286 Depreciation – Block of Assets 38 r.w. 43(6)(c), 50
285 1999-08-25 Chandiok (J.C.) vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (1999) 69 ITD 75 / (1999) (1999) 238 ITR (ITAT) 89 64 TTJ 1 Casual & Non-recurring 10(3) r.w. 2 & 5
286 1999-11-08 Asstt. CWT vs. Davender Kumar Jain (Delhi) (2000) 67 TTJ 1 Wealth Tax – Asset – Shares 2(e)
287 1999-12-02 Kailash Moudgil vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (2000) 72 ITD 97 / (2000) 67 TTJ 145 (2001) 248 ITR (AT) 59 Appellate Tribunal / Block Assessment 255(3) / 158BG r.w. 158BC
288 1999-12-02 Vidhu Agarwal vs. Dy. CIT (Del.) (2000) 67 TTJ 145 Tribunal – Appeal 255(3)
289 1999-12-06 Shanker Rice Co. vs. ITO (Asr.) (2000) 72 ITD 139 / (2000) 67 TTJ 84 249 ITR (AT) 44 Accounts – Methods of Accounting – Estimation of profits 145
290 1999-12-08 Narangs Hotels (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO (Mum.) (2000) 74 ITD 190 / (2000) 69 TTJ 384 (2001) 249 ITR (AT) 1 Industrial Company – Depreciation – Bad Debt 2(8)(c), 32
291 2000-02-18 T. I. & M. Ltd. vs. Asstt. CWT (Chennai) (2000) 73 ITD 180 (2001) 247 ITR (AT) 15 (2000) 68 TTJ 145 Wealth Tax – Charge of Tax – Companies 3 r.w. 40(3)
292 2000-05-09 First Leasing Co. of India Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Chennai) (2000) 75 ITD 197 / (2001) 70 TTJ 331/(2001) 250 ITR (AT) 1 Depreciation / Revision 32 / 263
293 2000-07-17 ITO vs. Hatsu Takayanagi (Delhi) (2000) 74 ITD 143 / (2000) 69 TTJ 421 (2001) 249 ITR (AT) 19 Appellate Tribunal – Procedure – KVSS 255 r.w. 90 & 91
294 2000-07-17 Shiv Narain Karmendra Narain vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (2000) 74 ITD 145 / 69TTJ 420 / (2001) 249 ITR (AT)94 Kar Vivad Samadhan Scheme – Appellate Tribunal 255 r.w. 90 & 91 of the Finance (No. 2)
295 2000-07-31 Arathi Shenoy vs. Jt. CIT (Bang.) (2000) 75 ITD 100 / (2000) 69 TTJ 779 (2000) 246 ITR (AT) 1 Association of Persons / Capital Gain 4./45
296 2000-08-08 Iqbal Chand Khurana vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (2000) 75 ITD 177 / (2000)69 TTJ 286 (2001) 252 ITR (AT) 17 Lottery – Meaning – Business Income 80TT
297 2000-08-18 ITO vs. Chloride India Ltd. (Cal.) (2000) 75 ITD 69 / (2000) 69 TTJ 609 DTAA – Foreign Companies 90 r.w Art. 13(2)
298 2000-09-12 Shaw Scott Distilleries (P.) Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Cal.) (AT) 14 (2001) 76 ITD 89 / (2001) 70 TTJ 321 / (2002) 235 ITR Manufacturer – New Industrial undertaking 80HH
299 2000-11-16 SAIPEM Spa. vs. ITO (Delhi) (2001) 78 ITD 101 / (2001) 70 TTJ 1 (2002) 254 ITR (AT) 26 Salary – Perquisite – steel Banker 17(2)
300 2001-02-16 IFB Agro Industries Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Cal.) (2002) 83 ITD 96 / (2003) 78 TTJ 177 (2003) 261 ITR (AT) 17 Exports total turnover 80HHC
301 2001-03-22 Surat District Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. ITO (Ahd.) (2003) 85 ITD 1 / (2003) 78 TTJ 1 (2003) 262 ITR (AT) 1 Co-op. Soc. – Special deduction – precedent 80P r.w. 18 & 24
302 2001-04-03 Simbhaoli Industries (P.) Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (2001) 78 ITD 161 / (2001) 72 TTJ 388 (2001) 251 ITR (AT) 35 Revision – order under section 143(1)(a) 263 r.w 143(1)(a)
303 2001-05-18 Hem Raj Vijay Kumar & Co. vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (2001) 78 ITD 304 / (2001) 72 TTJ 648 Previous Year / Revision of orders prejudicial to interests 3 / 263 r.w. 3
304 2001-06-11 Cadell Weaving Mills Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Mum.) (2002) 80 ITD 79 / (2003) 78 TTJ 369 Book Profits – Zero Tax Companies 115J, 10(3)
305 2001-07-17 Pearl Polymers Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi) (2002) 80 ITD 1 / (2002) 74 TTJ 1 (2002) 255 ITR (AT) 76 Exporters – Special Bench 80HHC
306 2001-09-05 Highway Cycle Industries Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Chd) (2002) 74 TTJ 171 (2002) 255 ITR (AT) 105 Investment Deposit Account – Business Profits – Appellate 32AB, 254
307 2001-09-05 Highway Cycle Industries Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Chd.) (2002) 74 TTJ 171 Investment Deposit Account 32AB
308 2001-09-27 Jagan Nath Sayal vs. Asstt. CGT (Delhi) (2001) 79 ITD 114 / (2000)73 TTJ 513 Gift Tax – Rectification of mistakes – apparent from record 34
309 2001-11-13 Asstt. CIT vs. Rajinikanth (A.) (Mad.) 75 TTJ 511 (2002) 81 ITD 84 / (2002) Exemption – Insurance Policy Wealth Tax – Asset / 2(e) / 5(1)(vi) r.w. 2(e)
310 2001-11-13 Asstt. CIT A. Rajnikant (2002) 81 ITD 84 / (2002) 75 TTJ 511 (2003) 261 ITR (AT) 98 Wealth Tax – Asset / Exemption – annuity 2(e) / 5(1)(vi) r.w. 2(e)
311 2002-05-10 Octavius Steel & Co. Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT (Kol) (2002) 83 ITD 87 / (2003) 78 TTJ 170 (2003) 260 ITR (AT) 109 Capital Gains – Conversation investment in stock-in-trade 45(5) 2(47)(vi)
312 2002-08-01 Oil & National Gas Corpn. Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Delhi.) (2002) 83 ITD 151 / (2002)77 TTJ 387 (2003) 261 ITR (AT) 1 Business Loss – Expenditure– Foreign exchange loss 28(i) r.w. 37(1) & 43 A
313 2002-08-29 Rajeev Enterprises vs. AO (Jp.) (2003) 78 TTJ 330 (2003) 261 ITR (AT) 34 Export – Interest –Business Receipt 80HHC
314 2002-10-04 Eicher Tractors Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT(Delhi) (2003) 84 ITD 49 / (2002) 77 TTJ 681 (2003) 261 ITR (AT) 52 Guest House Expenses 37 (4) r.w. 30 & 31
315 2002-10-25 Asstt. CIT vs. K. S. Shetty & Co. (Chennai) (2003) 81 TTJ 158 / (2003) 87 ITD 259 / (2003) 263 ITR (AT) 71 Business / Loss – Chitfund 28(1) & 37(1)
316 2002-10-25 Tamilnadu Minerals Ltd. vs. IAC (Chennai) (2003) 81 TTJ 161 / (2003)87 ITD 307 Exports – granite – process applied. 80HHC
317 2002-11-28 J. H. & Co. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 150 Export Market Development Allowance 35(B)
318 2002-11-29 Bakulesh T. Shah vs. Dy. CIT (Mum.) 78 TTJ 358 (2002) 81 ITD 89 / (2002) DTAA – Constitution of India/ Income Accrual 91 r.w. art. 371F(k) & (n) / 5
319 2002-11-29 Ratanchand Chordia M. vs. ITO (Mad.) (1982) 1 SOT 78 Income from House Property – Annual value 23(1)
320 2002-12-12 Surendra Engg. Corpn. vs. Asstt. CIT (Mum.) (2003) 78 TTJ 347 / (2003) 86 ITD 121 Export – Deductions – Indirect Tax – Incentives 80HHC
321 2003-01-08 Asstt. CIT vs. Ajax Investment Ltd. (Ahd.) vs. Acro Prelish Inv. Ltd. (2003) 78 TTJ 847 (2003) 263 ITR (AT) 42 Company – Subsidiary 2(18)(b)
322 2003-01-08 Dy. CIT vs. Catholic Syrian Bank Ltd. (Coch) (2004) 82 TTJ 181 / (2004) 88 ITD 185 Bad debts 36(1)(vii) & 36(1)(viia)
323 2003-02-20 Jai Hind Co-op. Housing Society Ltd vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 39 / (1983)3 ITD 625 Income – Society – Premium– Capital or Revenue Receipt 4
324 2003-02-27 ITO vs. Sapt Textile Products India Ltd. (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 269 Amounts not deductible Remuneration to Direct Tax 40(c) & 40A(5)
325 2003-02-27 Sapt. Textile Products India Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 269 Company – Remuneration 40(c), 40 A(5)
326 2003-02-27 Someshwar Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 81 Appeal / Depreciation 246 (c), 32 & 139(5)
327 2003-03-07 Anil Sanghi vs. Asstt. CIT (Delhi) (2003) 85 ITD 73 / (2003) 79 ITD 517 (2003) 263 ITR (AT) 30 Appellate Tribunal – Appeals – Block Assessment 253 r.w. 249 (4)
328 2003-05-08 Chhabria Trust vs. Asstt. CIT (2003) 80 TTJ 861 / (2003) 87 ITO 181 (2003) 264 ITR (AT) 12 Block of assets – Depreciation Capital Gain 2(11) r.w. 50
329 2003-05-27 Shriram Chits & Investment (P) Ltd. vs. Asstt. CIT, Chennai (2003) 263 ITR (AT) 65 Accounting – Chit fund Depreciation 32, 145
330 2003-07-03 Jyotindra H. Shodhan vs. ITO (Ahd.) (2003) 81 TTJ 1 / (2003) 87 ITD 312 (2003) 264 ITR (AT) 1 Capital Gain – Exemption – Date of transfer 54E
331 2003-07-04 Walkeshwar Triveni Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. vs. ITO (Mum.) (2004) 88 ITD 159 / (2003) 80 TTJ 673 Income – Mutuality – co-op. society – transferee – transferer 4
332 2003-07-25 Ramaiah Reddy C. vs. Asstt. CIT (Bang.) (2003) 81 TTJ 1044 / (2003) 87 ITD 439 Block Assessment – Search & Seizure 132(1), 158 BE
333 2003-08-12 Nawal Kishore & Sons Jewellers vs. Dy. CIT (Lucknow) (2003) 81 TTJ 362 / (2003) 87 ITD 407 (2004) 265 ITR (AT) 275 Block Assessment Procedure – Validity 143(2), 158BC, 142, 145(2)
334 2003-08-14 ICICI Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Mum.) (2003) 81 TTJ 37(2003) 87 ITD 53 Depreciation – leasing 32(1) & 43(1)
335 2003-08-14 Mid East Portfolio Management Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Mum.) (2003) 81 TTJ 37 / (2003) 87 ITD 537 Depreciation – Sales & Lease back 32(1) & 43(1)
336 2003-08-14 Sushil Kumar & Co. vs. Jt. CIT (Cal.) (2003) 81 TTJ 864 / (2004) 88 ITD 35 Business Income – Mesne Pofits 4, 28(1)
337 2003-08-14 West Coast Paper Mills Ltd. vs. Jt. CIT (Mum.) (2003) 81 TTJ 37 Depreciation 32(1) & 43(1)
338 2003-08-29 Dy. CIT vs. CWC Wires (P) Ltd. (Hyd.) (2004) 89 ITD 1 (2004) 83 TTJ 1 Business disallowance exim duty paid in advance cannot be allowed as deduction 43B
339 2003-09-30 ITO vs. Gujjarmal Amrit Lal (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 495 HUF – Interest to partners 40(b)
340 2003-10-23 Dy. CIT vs. Reliance Industries Ltd. (Mum.) (2004) 82 TTJ 765 (2004) 88 ITD 273 Income – Capital Revenue Receipt – Precedent – Tribunal 4
341 2003-12-03 Twenty First Century Steels Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT (Del.) (2004) 82 TTJ 798 Investment – Deposit – Purchase 32AB
342 2003-12-18 Jt. CIT vs. Poddar Projects Ltd. (2004) 82 TTJ 740 / (2004) (Cal.) 88 ITD 247 Income from House Property – Assessed value 22 & 23(1)(b)
343 2004-01-27 Assam Tea Co. vs. ITO (Asr.) (2004) 82 TTJ 729 Reassessment 147(a
344 2004-01-27 Assam Tea Co. vs. Income-tax Officer [2005] 92 ITD 85 (Amritsar) (SB)[27-01-2004] Reopening – on the basis of suspicion and alleged statement of third party 147
345 2004-02-25 Lalson Enterprises vs. Dy. CIT(Delhi) (2004) 82 TTJ 1048(2004) 89 ITD 25 Export – adjustment of loss 80HHC
346 2004-02-25 Lalsons Enterprises vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2004] 89 ITD 25 (Delhi) (SB)[25-02-2004] U/s. 80HHC(3)(c) – Setting off of losses from eligible business against income from other business – Reduction of 90% of receipts on net interest and not gross interest 80HHC
347 2004-03-05 East West RSWE (P) Ltd. vs. Dy.CIT (Delhi) (2004) 89 ITD 259 Rectification – Powers of Tribunal cannot review the order 254(2)
348 2004-03-05 East West Rescue (P.) Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2004] 89 ITD 259 (Delhi) (SB)[05-03-2004] Power of tribunal to review it’s order – power of third member to consider a case law or provision of law not referred earlier 254(2)
349 2004-03-23 Appollo Tyres Ltd. vs. Asst. CIT (Delhi) (2004) 89 ITD 235 Actual cost – Foreign Exchange earned on cancellation of contract has to be reduced from cost of plant and machinery 43A
350 2004-03-23 Apollo Tyres Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2004] 89 ITD 235 (Delhi) (SB)[23-03-2004] Forex loss on rate fluctuation – exchange loss on interest on foreign loans borrowed for acquiring capital assets 43A
351 2004-04-29 Blackie & Sons (India) Ltd. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1983) 3 SOT 72 Perquisists – Medical Expenses 17, 40 A(5)
352 2004-05-24 ITO vs. Srinivasan (K.N.) (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 3 Capital Gains – Residence 54
353 2004-05-26 Arvindbhai H. Shah vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2004] 91 ITD 101 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[26-05-2004] Rectification application before ITAT beyond period of limitation – time limit of 4 years u/s. 254(2) applies both to suo moto action by ITAT as well as to request made by the parties. 254
354 2004-06-03 Ram Karandas Jagannath vs. ITO (Delhi) (1983) 3 SOT 13 HUF – Individual 40(b)
355 2004-06-16 ITO vs. Ahmedabad Kaiser-I-Hind Mills. Ltd. (Ahd.) (1982) 3 SOT 1 Business Expenditure – Guarantee Commission 37
356 2004-06-25 ITO vs. Saragi Bros. (Cal.) (1983) 3 SOT 202 Capital or Revenue – Sale of shares 28(i)
357 2004-06-30 ITO vs. Ramasamy (A.Al.) (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 22 Conversion of Foreign Currency Rule 115
358 2004-08-19 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Manjara Shetkari Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd [2004] 91 ITD 361 (Mumbai) (SB)[19-08-2004] applicability of section 40A(2) to co-operative society 40A(2)
359 2004-08-23 G & Co. vs. ITO (Bom.) (1982) 1 SOT 142 / (1983) 3 ITD 566 Export Market Allowance 35B(1)
360 2004-09-22 Bai Sonabai Hirji Agiary Trust vs. Income-tax Officer [2005] 93 ITD 70 (Mumbai) (SB)[22-09-2004] constitution of special bench 255(3)
361 2004-10-08 Vinod Khatri vs. Dy. CIT (Del.) (2002) 82 TTJ 911 Tribunal – Filing Form 253(b)
362 2004-10-08 Bidyut Kumar Sett vs. Income-tax Officer [2005] 92 ITD 148 (Kolkata) (SB)[08-10-2004] Filing fees in case of penalty appeal before ITAT 253(6)
363 2004-10-20 G.T.O. vs. Padma Srinivasan (Smt.) (Mad.) (1983) 3 SOT 157 Gift – Chargeability 3
364 2004-12-01 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Venkateswar Investment & Finance (P.) Ltd. [2005] 93 ITD 177 (Kolkata) (SB)[01-12-2004] Losses suffered on purchase and sale of shares by company whose principal business is granting loans & advance – whether to be considered as speculative losses. 73
365 2004-12-13 Jaihind Bottling Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2005] 1 SOT 1 (Mumbai) (SB)[13-12-2004] Inclusion of such assets on which 100% deduction was allowed by virtue of section 32(1)(ii) in ‘block of assets’ for the purpose of section 50 50, 32
366 2004-12-27 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Apsara Processors (P.) Ltd. [2005] 2 SOT 132 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[27-12-2004] Amendment in section 271(1)(c) with effect from 1-4-2003 – Prospective/retrospective? 271(1)(c )
367 2005-01-28 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, vs. Concord Commercials (P.) Ltd. [2005] 95 ITD 117 (Mumbai) (SB)[28-01-2005] Losses – In speculation business – only if a company is hit by Explanation to section 73 73, 71, 56
368 2005-01-31 Raj Kumar Chawla vs. Income-tax Officer [2005] 1 SOT 934 (Delhi) (SB)[31-01-2005] return u/s 148 and issue of notice u/s 143(2) 143, 144, 148
369 2005-02-02 Peerless Securities Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax [2005] 94 ITD 89 (Kolkata) (SB)[08-02-2005] capital asset- enduring benefit test, amount, bringing in existence assets, payment of admission fee 37(1)
370 2005-02-14 Income-tax Officer vs. Bir Engg. Works [2005] 94 ITD 164 (Amritsar) (SB)[14-02-2005] binding nature of instructions/circulars on department, tribunal’s power of review, tribunal’s power to adjudicate debatable issue u/s 254(2) 119, 254(2), 254
371 2005-04-25 Nirma Industries Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, [2005] 95 ITD 199 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[25-04-2005] disallowance of professional charges, preliminary expenses, deduction of interest on deposit with banks u/s 80-I, interest on borrowed money, term ‘related concern’ and Excessive or unreasonable payments, immediate nexus with industrial undertaking for section 80-I, deduction under section 80-I on transport rent income, utilisation of amount withdrawn from deposit account 40A(12), 35D, 80-I, 80HH, 36(1)(iii), 40A(2),32AB
372 2005-05-25 Smt. Mahesh Kumari Batra vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, [2005] 95 ITD 152 (Amritsar) (SB)[25-05-2005] Block assessment in search cases – defect in notice, Unexplained investments – inadequate family expenditure  158BC, 158BA, 147, 292B, 69
373 2005-06-07 Promain Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2005] 95 ITD 489 (Delhi) (SB)[07-06-2005] powers of the tribunal to decide issue relating to validity of search 254, 132, 158BC
374 2005-06-23 B. Sorabji vs. Income-tax Officer, [2005] 95 ITD 540 (Mumbai) (SB)[23-06-2005] allowability of deduction u/s 80HHC 80HHC 
375 2005-07-15 Wallfort Shares & Stock Brokers Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer, Ward 4(2)(1) [2005] 96 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB)[15-07-2005] Tax avoidance, Dividend stripping, taxability of income distributed by mutual fund, conflict between Chapter III and section 14A, inter head set off of losses 4, 28(i), 94(7), 14A, 71
376 2005-08-22 ABN Amro Bank NV vs. Assistant Director of Income-tax, International Taxation-I [2005] 97 ITD 89 (Kolkata) (SB)[22-08-2005] allowability of interest paid by PE to HO outside India and TDS thereon 37(1), 40(a)(i), 195, 201
377 2005-08-31 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Spl. Range-14 vs. Royal Jordanians Airlines [2006] 98 ITD 1 (Delhi) (SB)[31-08-2005] immunity from tax to a sovereign, interest under section 234C has been charged in notice of demand under section 156 but not in body of assessment order 4, 234B, 234A, 234C, 154
378 2005-09-25 Wall Street Construction Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-12 4181 of 2000,4183 of 2000,4184 of 2000, IT APPEAL NOS. 4181, 4183 AND 4184 (MUM.) OF 2000 allowability of Business expenditure where an assessee is following project completion 37(1), 36(iii)
379 2005-10-28 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, CC-XXVIII vs. Surya Kanta Dalmia [2005] 97 ITD 235 (Kolkata) (SB)[28-10-2005] addition on account of disclosure in Voluntary Disclosure Scheme (VDIS), 1997 unsustainable where identity, creditworthiness and genuineness proved 68
380 2005-11-03 Dewan Chand Amrit Lal vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Hissar Range [2006] 98 ITD 200 (Chandigarh) (SB)[03-11-2005] with regard to provisions of sections 271D and 271E, determination of period of limitation for purpose of section 275 275, 271D and 271E
381 2005-11-09 Vahid Paper Converters vs. Income-tax Officer, Vapi Ward-4, Daman [2006] 98 ITD 165 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[09-11-2005] allowability of depreciation while computing deductions under Chapter VI-A 80-I
382 2005-11-25 Housing & Urban Development Corpn. Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-24 [2006] 5 SOT 918 (Delhi) (SB)[25-11-2005] taxability of investments and interest 2(7), 5
383 2005-11-30 Durga Prashad Goyal vs. Income-tax Officer, Ward-I, Moga [2006] 98 ITD 227 (Amritsar) (SB)[30-11-2005] initiation of reassessment proceedings on the basis of information from investigation wing 147
384 2006-01-08 Avada Trading Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Spl. Circle 18(1) [2006] 6 SOT 1 (Mumbai) (SB)[18-01-2006] taxability of interest on refund under section 244A(1) 244A, 143(1)(a)
385 2006-01-20 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Spl. Range-26 vs. Warner Bros. (F.E.) Inc. [2006] 99 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB)[20-01-2006] CBDT Instructions to subordinate authorities 119
386 2006-02-20 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corpn. [2006] 100 ITD 187 (Mumbai) (SB)[20-02-2006] scope of powers of High Powered Committee was constituted by Government of India 254
387 2006-03-10 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Cir.1 (1), Ernakulam vs. Apollo Tyres Ltd. [2006] 6 SOT 478 (Delhi) (SB)[10-03-2006] order passed by a special bench can be rectified, taxability of gain earned on cancellation of foreign exchange forward contract and roll over charges 254, 255
388 2006-03-16 Kwality Milk Foods Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 100 ITD 199 (Chennai) (SB)[16-03-2006] section 43B is curative in nature and as such retrospective 43B
389 2006-03-24 Ashima Syntex Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 100 ITD 247 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[24-03-2006] allowability of expenditure incurred on issuance of wholly convertible debentures 37(1)
390 2006-03-24 AMP Spg. & Wvg. Mills (P.) Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer [2006] 100 ITD 142 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[24-03-2006] speculative loss  73
391 2006-03-29 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Montgomery Emerging Markets Fund [2006] 100 ITD 217 (Mumbai) (SB)[29-03-2006] Set off-of from one source against income from another source under same head of income 70
392 2006-04-07 Atma Ram Properties (P.) Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 8 SOT 741 (Delhi) (SB)[07-04-2006] taxability of rental income and income from sale of land and building 28, 28(i)
393 2006-04-10 Punjab State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-II, Chandigarh [2006] 102 ITD 1 (Chandigarh) (SB)[10-04-2006] computing deduction under section 80M  80M 
394 2006-04-26 Merit Enterprises vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-1 [2006] 101 ITD 1 (Hyderabad) (SB)[26-04-2006] retrospective levy of surcharge on tax charged under section 113 in respect of undisclosed income of block period 113, 158BC,113
395 2006-05-05 Sudipto Sarkar vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 101 ITD 229 (Kolkata) (SB)[05-05-2006] Entertainment expenditure, motor car upkeep expenses 37(1), 37(2), 37(2A)
396 2006-05-17 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Oman International Bank SAOG [2006] 100 ITD 285 (Mumbai) (SB)[17-05-2006] no need to prove debt written off is indeed a bad debt, sanctity of Third Member decision and Special Bench decision 36(1)(vii), 255
397 2006-05-19 Indian Plywood Mfg. Co. Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 100 ITD 318 (Mumbai) (SB)[19-05-2006] ascertained liability 32AB 
398 2006-06-07 Pallonji Shapoorji & Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Wealth-tax, Special Range 23, Mumbai [2006] 102 ITD 101 (Mumbai) (SB)[07-06-2006] wealth tax – charge of tax 3, 4 of wealth tax act
399 2006-07-07 Punitaben Karsanbhai Patel Oral Specific Deferred Family Trust vs. Income-tax Officer [2006] 103 ITD 175 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[07-07-2006] once income of a trust, assessed on substantive basis and liability finally settled under Kar Vivad Samadhan Scheme, 1998, same income could not be again assessed in hands of corresponding beneficiaries who had been assessed on a protective basis 263 
400 2006-07-10 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Peerless Developers Ltd. [2006] 103 ITD 349 (Kolkata) (SB)[10-07-2006] appeal not maintainable if tax effect is low even when it involves a legal issue 253 
401 2006-07-25 Southern Travels vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 103 ITD 198 (Chennai) (SB)[25-07-2006] set-off brought forward depreciation against capital gains of current year not permissible 32
402 2006-08-18 Mange Ram Mittal vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 103 ITD 389 (Delhi) (SB)[18-08-2006] procedure for Block assessment in search cases 158BC, 158BB
403 2006-09-14 R.M. Valliappan vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2006] 103 ITD 63 (Chennai) (SB)[14-09-2006] taxability of a membership card of a stock exchange as a capital asset 2(14)
404 2006-09-29 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle II, Meerut vs. Padam Prakash (HUF) [2007] 104 ITD 1 (Delhi) (SB)[29-09-2006] sanctity of Third Member decision and Special Bench decision, point of taxation of enhanced compensation, disputed interest taxable when it is finally determined 225,45,5
405 2006-10-06 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Usha Martine Industries Ltd. [2007] 104 ITD 249 (Kolkata) (SB)[06-10-2006] adjustments for calculation of Minimum alternate tax and effect of wealth tax thereon 115JA
406 2006-10-19 Inspecting Assistant Commissioner, (Assessment) Range IV-C, Mumbai vs. Saurashtra Trust [2007] 106 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB)[19-10-2006] exemption for Charitable or religious trust 11, 2(15), 4(3)(i) of Indian Income-tax Act, 1922
407 2006-10-27 Vijaysinh R. Rathod vs. Income-tax Officer, Ward-3, Vapi [2007] 106 ITD 153 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB)[27-10-2006] taxability of sale of occupancy right 45 , section 4 of the Dadra and Nagar Haveli Land Reforms Regulation 1971
408 2006-11-08 Rajiv Piramal Investments (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 5(6) [2007] 106 ITD 67 (Mumbai) (SB)[08-11-2006] diminution in market rate of shares has to be estimated on an appropriate and logical consideration of factual position 48 
409 2006-11-17 Hiralal Lokchandani vs. Income-tax Officer, Jharsuguda Ward, Jharsuguda [2007] 106 ITD 45 (Kolkata) (SB)[17-11-2006] determination of fair market value of of asset 55 
410 2006-11-23 Arihant Builders, Developers & Investors (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle I(1), Indore Appeal No.952 of 1994 procedure and constitution of Special Bench, issuance of notice U/s 143(2) after issuance of refund, Rejection of accounts, use of section 44AD as a guideline for purpose of applying a particular net profit 255 , 143, 145 , 44AD
411 2006-11-30 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle, Buland Shahr vs. Allied Construction [2007] 105 ITD 1 (Delhi) (SB)[30-11-2006] taxability of interest income on FDRs, Rejection of accounts, presumptive taxation where gross receipts exceeded prescribed limit 56, 145, 44AD
412 2007-01-12 Samaj Kalyan Parishad, Modinagar vs. Income-tax Officer, Central Circle-XXVI, New Delhi [2007] 105 ITD 29 (Delhi) (SB)[12-01-2007] Exemption of income from property held under 11, 2(15) and 13
413 2007-02-15 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range 25, Mumbai vs. Mukund Ltd. [2007] 106 ITD 231 (Mumbai) (SB)[15-02-2007] allowability of expenditure for obtaining leasehold rights 37(1)
414 2007-03-05 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Cir. 2(2), Cochin vs. Norasia Lines (Malta) Ltd. [2007] 107 ITD 301 (Cochin) (SB)[05-03-2007] applicability of interest, obligation to pay advance tax in case of a non-resident governed by section 172, Rectification of mistakes Apparent from records 234B, 234C, 172
415 2007-03-06 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax vs. DHL Operations BV [2007] 13 SOT 581 (Mumbai) (SB)[06-03-2007] powers of the Tribunal  255 
416 2007-03-09 Smt. Krishna Verma vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Investigation Circle, Faridabad [2007] 107 ITD 1 (Delhi) (SB)[09-03-2007] validity and defects in notice issued under section 158BC 158BC, 143, 148, 132
417 2007-03-14 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Range 8(3) vs. Syncome Formulations (I) Ltd. [2007] 106 ITD 193 (Mumbai) (SB)[14-03-2007] working of deduction under section 80HHC 80HHC, 115JA
418 2007-04-17 Income-tax Officer, Ward-19(3)-4, Mumbai vs. Ms. Sushila M. Jhaveri [2007] 107 ITD 327 (Mumbai) (SB)[17-04-2007] allowability of exemption where more than one residential house purchased 54, 54F
419 2007-04-27 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-I, Tirupur vs. Rogini Garments [2007] 108 ITD 49 (Chennai) (SB)[27-04-2007] Principle of legislative intention 80HHC, 80-IA
420 2007-07-09 Y. Subbaraju & Co. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2004] 91 ITD 118 (Bangalore) (SB)[09-07-2004] Existence of material is a sine qua non for taking action under section 158BD 158BD
421 2007-07-20 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 4(1) vs. Glaxo Smithkline Consumer Healthcare Ltd. [2007] 107 ITD 343 (Chandigarh) (SB)[20-07-2007] deduction under section 43B, in respect of payment of excise duty, tax etc 43B
422 2007-08-14 Dhariwal Industries Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax (Inv.), Circle-2(1)/Additional Commissioner of Income-tax, Range-1, Pune [2008] 111 ITD 379 (Pune) (SB)[14-08-2007] meaning of the term ‘tobacco preparations’ and ‘chewing tobacco’ 80-I, 80-IA
423 2007-08-17 Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income-tax, City-1, Mumbai [2008] 111 ITD 190 (Mumbai) (SB)[17-08-2007] concept of new undertaking 80-IA
424 2007-08-31 Pradeep Agencies v. ITO [2007] 18 SOT 12 (Delhi) (SB)/[2007] 111 TTJ 346 (Delhi) (SB) taxation in the hands of the ‘right person’ 167B, 67A
425 2007-08-31 Bhagwad Swarup Shri Shri Devraha Baba Memorial Shri Hari Parmarth Dham Trust vs. Commissioner of Income-tax, Dehradun [2008] 111 ITD 175 (Delhi) (SB)[31-08-2007] deemed registration of trust if order granting/refusing registration not passed within stipulated time 12AA, 12A
426 2007-09-07 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-16, Kolkata vs. ITC Ltd. [2008] 112 ITD 57 (Kolkata) (SB)[07-09-2007] allowability of business expenditure 37(1), 37(2), 36(1)(iii), 40A(2)
427 2007-10-18 Rammanohar Singh vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle Satna [2008] 170 Taxman 79 (Jabalpur) (SB) (MAG)[18-10-2007] allowability of Business expenditure where higher charges paid for obtaining substancial earnings 37(1)
428 2007-10-26 New India Industries Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 16(1), New Delhi [2007] 18 SOT 51 (Delhi) (SB)/[2007] 112 TTJ 917 (Delhi)(SB) Bad debts 36(1)(vii), 36(1)(viia)
429 2007-11-16 Voltas Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Wealth-tax, Circle 7(3), Mumbai [2008] 113 ITD 19 (Mumbai) (SB)[16-11-2007] Deemed wealth 4, 2(m) of wealth tax act 269UA of income tax act
430 2007-11-30 Medicare Investments Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-20, New Delhi [2008] 114 ITD 34 (Delhi) (SB)[30-11-2007] allowability of deduction for loss incurred on sale of NCDs 28
431 2007-11-30 RBF Rig Corpn. LIC (RBFRC) vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-1, Dehradun [2007] 109 ITD 141 (Delhi) (SB)[30-11-2007] taxability of payment of tax on behalf of employee as a non-monetary perquisite 10(10CC), 17(2)(iv)
432 2008-02-15 Aquarius Travels (P.) Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer, Co. Ward-2(3), New Delhi [2008] 111 ITD 53 (Delhi) (SB) Retrospective applicability of section 14A, as amended by Finance Act, 2002 Section 14A of IT Act
433 2008-02-15 Amway India Enterprises vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-1(1), New Delhi [2008] 111 ITD 112 (Delhi – Trib.) (i) Criteria for deciding nature of expenditure as to whether it is capital or revenue?
(ii) Depreciation on Computer Software
Section 37(1) and 32 of IT Act
434 2008-02-20 Narang Overseas (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle 36, Mumbai [2008] 111 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB) Taxability of mesne profit Section 4 of IT Act
435 2008-03-01 Sumit Bhattacharya vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 16(1), Mumbai [2008] 112 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB) Taxability of amount received on redemption of ‘Stock Appreciation Rights’ granted by employer Section 15 r/w. 56 and 45 of IT Act
436 2008-03-07 Income-tax Officer, Ward-I, Murshidabad vs. Kenaram Saha & Subhash Saha [2009] 116 ITD 1 (Kolkata) (SB) Cash payments exceeding prescribed limits Section 40(3) of IT Act, r/w Rule 6DD of the IT Rules
437 2008-03-28 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-13, New Delhi vs. Mayur Recreational & Development Ltd. [2008] 113 ITD 181 (Delhi) (SB) Income from House Property – Estimation of ALV Section 23 of IT Act
438 2008-05-09 Gujarat Credit Corpn. Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-4, Ahmedabad [2008] 113 ITD 133 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) (i) Limitation Period for completion of assessment, in light of proviso to section 147
(ii) Non-disclosure of primary facts – whether re-opening justified?
(iii) Speculation Loss – Non delivery of shares
(iv) Penalty – For concealment of income
Section 73, 147, 153 and 271(1)(c) of IT Act
439 2008-05-30 Shri Kamrej Vibhag Sahakari Khand Udyog Mandli Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer, TDS 2, Surat [2008] 113 ITD 539 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Deduction of tax at source – payment to Contractors/sub-contractors Section 194C of the IT Act
440 2008-06-05 B.G. Chitale vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range 3, Solapur [2008] 115 ITD 97 (Pune) (SB) Whether process of standardization and pasteurization of milk does not amount to manufacture/production Section 80-I, r/w. section 80HHA of IT Act
441 2008-06-06 Smt. Krishna Verma vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Investigation Circle, Faridabad [2008] 113 ITD 655 (Delhi) (SB) Time limit for completion of Block assessment in search cases Section 158BE r/w. section 32 of IT Act
442 2008-07-11 Income-tax Officer, Ward 11(1), New Delhi vs. Ekta Promoters (P.) Ltd. [2008] 113 ITD 719 (Delhi) (SB) Whether provisions of section 234D are substantive and they cannot be applied retrospectively Section 234D of IT Act
443 2008-07-25 Manoj Aggarwal vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle 3, New Delhi [2008] 113 ITD 377 (Delhi) (SB) Undisclosed Income and Undisclosed Investment – Block assessment in search cases – Procedure Section 69 r. w. s. 68 & 69B, section 158B, section 158BD r. w. s. 158BC & 147, section section 143 r. w. s. 158BD and section 68 of IT Act
444 2008-08-22 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 16(1), Mumbai vs. Prakash L. Shah [2008] 115 ITD 167 (Mumbai) (SB) (i) Whether foreign exchange fluctuation gain is part of ‘Export turnover’ and cannot be treated as ‘Income from other sources’
(ii) Whether provision of section 155(13) has an overlapping effect on provisions of section 80HHC
Section 80HHC and Section 155 of IT Act
445 2008-08-25 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle III, Ferozepur vs. Sonu Verma [2008] 115 ITD 37 (Amritsar) (SB) Procedure for Block assessment in search cases Section 158BC r/w. section 132 of IT Act
446 2008-09-12 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Zaveri & Co. Exports [2008] 119 TTJ 1 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Treatment of DEPB receipt while computing deduction under section 80HHC Section 80HHC of IT Act
447 2008-09-19 Gujarat Gas Financial Services Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-4, Ahmedabad [2008] 115 ITD 218 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) (i) Interest Tax – Financial Company – Finance Lease, Inter Corporate Deposit & interest on delayed payment by debtors
(ii) Income Tax – Bad Debts
Section 2(5B) and 2(7) of Interest Tax Act and 36(1)(vii) r. w. s. 36(2) of Income Tax Act
448 2008-09-26 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-II, Meerut vs. Padam Prakash (HUF) [2009] 117 ITD 129 (Delhi) (SB) Scope of section 254(2) Section 254 of IT Act
449 2008-10-17 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Ahmedabad Circle-1, Ahmedabad vs. Ashima Syntex Ltd. [2009] 117 ITD 1 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Business expenditure – Year in which deductible Section 37(1) of IT Act
450 2008-10-20 Income-tax Officer, Ward 6(2)(2), Mumbai vs. Daga Capital Management (P.) Ltd. [2009] 117 ITD 169 (Mumbai) (SB) 14A – shares held as stock in trade Section 14A of IT Act
451 2008-11-19 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-33, Mumbai vs. Bhaumik Colour (P.) Ltd. [2009] 118 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB) Deemed dividend u/s. 2(22)(e) Section 2(22)(e) of IT Act
452 2008-12-29 Maruti Countrywide Auto Financial Services Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer, Ward 6(2), Delhi [2009] 29 SOT 151 (Delhi) (SB) Meaning of Interest Section 2(7) r/w. 8(2) of Interest Tax Act
453 2009-01-14 Kuber Tobacco Products (P.) Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Co. Circle 5(1), New Delhi [2009] 28 SOT 292 (Delhi) (SB) Notice deemed to be valid in certain circumstances section 292BB of IT Act
454 2009-03-05 J.M. Baxi & Co. vs. Deputy Director of Income-tax (Intl. Tax)-2(1), Mumbai [2009] 117 ITD 131 (Mumbai) (SB) Time-limit for issuance of notice u/s. 148 Section 149 r/w. 163 of IT Act
455 2009-03-06 Income-tax Officer, Company Ward-VI(1), Chennai vs. Sak Soft Ltd. [2009] 30 SOT 55 (Chennai) (SB) reight, telecom charges or insurance – Deduction 10B Section 10B of IT Act
456 2009-04-06 Brahma Associates vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax (OSD), Circle 4, Pune [2009] 119 ITD 255 (Pune) (SB) Fulfillment of conditions u/s. 80-IB Section 80-IB of IT Act
457 2009-04-24 Rajalakshmi Mills Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer, Company Circle III, Coimbatore [2009] 31 SOT 353 (Chennai) (SB) (i) Inquiries u/s. 263
(ii) Disallowance of Gratuity
Section 263 and 40A(7) of IT Act
458 2009-06-23 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Range – II, Moradabad vs. Hindustan Mint & Agro Products (P.) Ltd. [2009] 119 ITD 107 (Delhi) (SB) Deduction of Profits and gains from industrial undertakings, etc., after certain dates/infrastructure undertakings Section 80-IA and 80HHC of IT Act
459 2009-07-10 Tata Communications Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range 1, Mumbai [2009] 121 ITD 384 (Mumbai) (SB) Application u/s. 254(2) Section 254 of IT Act
460 2009-07-31 Shree Capital Services Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-5, Kolkata [2009] 121 ITD 498 (Kolkata) (SB) Speculative Transactions u/s. 43(5) Section 43(5) of IT Act
461 2009-08-11 Topman Exports vs. Income-tax Officer, (OSD), 14(2), Mumbai [2009] 33 SOT 337 (Mumbai) (SB) (i) Business Income – DEPB Scheme – DFRC
(ii) Deduction u/s. 80HHC
(iii) Income form other sources – Interest on surplus funds
Section 28(iiid), 28(iiie), 80HHC and 56 of IT Act
462 2009-08-13 Asstt. Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Subhash Verma [2009] 125 TTJ 865 (Delhi) (SB) Undisclosed Income and Undisclosed Expenditure – Block assessment in search cases Section 158B and 69C of IT Act
463 2009-09-15 Concept Creations vs. Additional Commissioner of Income-tax, Range, Panipat [2009] 120 ITD 19 (Delhi) (SB) Can President, Senior Vice-President, Vice-President and Member of Tribunal practice before Tribunal Section 254 of IT Act and Rule 13E of ITAT Members (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 1963
464 2009-10-16 Kailash Nath & Associates vs. Income-tax Officer, Ward 31(2), New Delhi [2009] 121 ITD 563 (Delhi) (SB) Accrual of Income Section 5, r.w.s. 28(ii) and 4 of IT Act
465 2009-10-16 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, 12(2) vs. Manjula J. Shah [2010] 35 SOT 105 (Mumbai) (SB) Indexation u/s. 48 in case of capital assets acquired by way of gift Section 48 of IT Act
466 2009-10-30 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-18, New Delhi vs. Sushila Milk Specialities (P.) Ltd. [2010] 122 ITD 48 (Delhi) (SB) Inquiry before assessment – special audit u/s. 142(2A) Section 142(2A) of IT Act
467 2009-11-27 Income-tax Officer vs. Padam Prakash (HuF) [2010] 127 TTJ 311 (Delhi) (SB) Scope of section 254(2) Section 254 of IT Act
468 2010-01-04 DLF Universal Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range (Cent.)-I, New Delhi [2010] 36 SOT 1 (Delhi) (SB) Capital Gains – stock-in-trade converted into a capital asset and contributed to a firm as capital contribution section 2(47) of IT Act
469 2010-01-22 Maharashtra State Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 1(3), Mumbai [2010] 38 SOT 325 (Mumbai) (SB) section 80P vis-a-vis business of banking, section 80P of IT Act
470 2010-03-19 CLC & Sons (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 3(1), New Delhi [2010] 38 SOT 439 (Delhi) (SB) Scope of section 253 Section 253 of IT Act
471 2010-04-07 Triumph Securities Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle 40, Mumbai [2010] 39 SOT 139 (Mumbai) (SB) Block assessment in search cases – Computation of Undisclosed income Section 69, 132, 142, 158B and 158BB of IT Act
472 2010-04-09 Joint Commissioner of Income-tax1 vs. Thirani Chemicals Ltd. [2010] 40 SOT 530 (Delhi) (SB) Deduction of Profits and gains from hotels or industrial undertakings, etc., in backward areas Section 80HH r. w. s. 80-I of IT Act
473 2010-05-26 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax/Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Company Circle-IV(1), Chennai-34 vs. Mahindra Holidays & Resorts (India) Ltd [2010] 39 SOT 438 (Chennai) (SB) Accrual of Income Section 5 of IT Act
474 2010-06-30 Income-tax Officer, Ward 3, Panchkula vs. Raghbir Singh (HUF) [2010] 42 SOT 112 (Chandigarh) (SB) Liability to pay interest u/s. 234A and 234B Section 234A and 234B of IT Act
475 2010-06-30 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 1(3), Mumbai vs. Times Guaranty Ltd. [2010] 40 SOT 14 (Mumbai) (SB) Set off of Unabsorbed depreciation Section 32(2) of IT Act
476 2010-07-02 Rain Commodities Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-3(1), Hyderabad [2010] 40 SOT 265 (Hyderabad) (SB) Power of examining books of accounts for computing book profit of a company under section 115JB Section 115JB r. w. s. 115J of IT Act
477 2010-07-09 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, 2(1), Mumbai vs. Datacraft India Ltd. [2010] 40 SOT 295 (Mumbai) (SB) Allowance of Depreciation – routers/switches Section 32 of IT Act
478 2010-07-14 V.K. Natesan vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central, Circle-2, Kochi [2011] 9 taxmann.com 76 (Cochin) (SB) Revision of orders prejudicial to interests of revenue – two possible view Section 263, r. w. s. 271(1)(c) and 275 of IT Act
479 2010-07-16 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Range 7(2), Mumbai vs. Shreyas S. Morakhia [2010] 40 SOT 432 (Mumbai) (SB) Allowabality of bad debts written off Section 36(1)(vii) of IT Act
480 2010-07-30 Tecumseh India (P.) Ltd. vs. Additional Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-5, New Delhi [2010] 127 ITD 1 (Delhi) (SB) Non-compete fee – revenue expenditure – Allowability Section 37(1) of IT Act
481 2010-08-13 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (International Taxation)-1(1), Mumbai vs. Bank of Bahrain & Kuwait [2010] 41 SOT 290 (Mumbai) (SB) (i) Business Loss – Forward Contract
(ii) Income – Accrual -Guarantee Commission
(iii) Disallowance – 14A
Section 28(i), 5 and 14A of IT Act
482 2010-11-02 Zylog Systems Ltd. vs. Income-tax Officer, Company Ward- III [2011] 128 ITD 105 (Chennai) (SB) Deduction – 10B – Export oriented undertaking Section 10B of IT Act
483 2010-11-10 Sulzer India Ltd. vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax – Range 8(3), Mumbai [2010] 42 SOT 457 (Mumbai) (SB) Remission or cessation of trading liability Section 41(1) of IT Act
484 2011-01-07 Shri Padam Prakash (HUF) vs. Income-tax Officer, Ward-2(1), Meerut [2011] 9 taxmann.com 178 (Delhi) (SB) Subsequent application u/s. 254(2)-Tribunal-Power to entertain Section 254 of IT Act
485 2011-03-04 Rajeev Sureshbhai Gajwani vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-6, Baroda [2011] 129 ITD 145 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Deductions – Profits and gains from export of computer software – Non-discrimination – Non resident Assessee Section 80HHE of IT Act read with article 26 of DTAA between India and USA
486 2011-03-29 V.K. Natesan vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central, Circle-2, Kochi [2011] 130 ITD 19 (Mumbai) (SB) Power of Tribunal to extend stay of demand beyond period of 365 days Section 254 of IT Act
487 2011-04-25 Income-tax Officer-22(3)(4) vs. United Marine Academy [2011] 130 ITD 113 (Mumbai) (SB) Depreciable Asset – Provisions of section 50C Section 50C r. w. s. 50 of IT Act
488 2011-05-06 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Range-I, Dehradun vs. Clough Engineering Ltd. [2011] 11 taxmann.com 70 (Delhi) (SB) Double taxation relief – Where agreement exists Section 90 of IT Act read with articles 7 and 11 of the DTAA between India and Australia
489 2011-06-22 Dalal Broacha Stock Broking (P.) Ltd. vs. Additional Commissioner of Income-tax Range 4(1), Mumbai [2011] 11 taxmann.com 426 (Mumbai) (SB) Allowabality – Bonus or commission Section 36(1)(ii) of IT Act
490 2011-08-10 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 8(2) Mumbai vs. Summit Securities Ltd. [2011] 12 taxmann.com 372 (Mumbai) (SB) Procedure of Appellate Tribunal Section 255 of IT Act
491 2011-08-12 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, C.C. XX vs. Rajesh Kumar Drolia [2011] 12 taxmann.com 410 (Kolkata) (SB) Profits and gains from industrial undertakings other than infrastructural development undertakings Section 80IB of IT Act
492 2011-12-09 Nandi Steels Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-12(2), Bangalore [2012] 17 taxmann.com 93 (Bangalore) (SB) Carry forward and set-off of business losses Section 70 of IT Act
493 2012-02-13 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax Circle 2(3), Hyderabad
v.
Dr. B.V. Raju
[2012] 135 ITD 1 (Hyderabad) (SB) Taxability of non-compete fee 28(va)
494 2012-03-07 Deputy Commissioner of Income tax, Circle 8(2)
v.
Summit Securities Ltd
[2012] 135 ITD 99 (Mumbai) (SB) Computation of capital gains – Slump Sale 50B
495 2012-03-14 IndusInd Bank Ltd.
v.
Additional Commissioner of Income-tax, Special Range-15, Mumbai
[2012] 135 ITD 165 (Mumbai) (SB) Depreciation in the case of lease 32
496 2012-03-28 Maral Overseas Limited
v.
Additional Commissioner of Income-Tax
[2012] 136 ITD 177 (Indore – Trib.) (SB) Deduction u/s 10B 10B
497 2012-03-30 Tulip Hotels (P.) Ltd.
v.
Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax*
[2012] 136 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB) Scope of Third member judgment 255
498 2012-03-30 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corpn
v.
Deputy Director of Income-tax (IT), Range-2(1), Mumbai
[2012] 136 ITD 66 (Mumbai) (SB) Taxability & deductibility of interest 4
499 2012-05-21 All Cargo Global Logistics Ltd.
v.
Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-44
[2012] 137 ITD 26 (Mumbai) (SB) Term – ”aggrieved” 253
500 2012-05-25 Vishnu Anant Mahajan
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 5, Baroda
[2012] 137 ITD 189 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Application of 14A 14, 14A
501 2012-05-30 Golden Tobacco Ltd.
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax
[2012] 147 TTJ 1 (Mumbai) (SB)[30-05-2012] Scope of directions of special bench ruling 254
502 2012-06-11 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-2, Jodhpur
v.
Shree Ram Lime Products Ltd
[2012] 137 ITD 220 (Jodhpur) (SB) Time limit for completion of block assessment 158BE
503 2012-07-06 All Cargo Global Logistics Ltd.
v.
Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-44
[2012] 137 ITD 287 (Mumbai) (SB) Scope of search proceeding & Deduction u/s 80-IA 80IA, 153A
504 2012-07-20 Madhu Jayanti International Ltd.
v.
Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle -1, Kolkata
[2012] 137 ITD 377 (Kolkata) (SB) Applicability of deduction u/s 10A to blending & processing of tea 10A, 10AA, 10B
505 2012-08-03 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax-8(3)
v.
Sulzer India Ltd.Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax-8(3)
[2012] 138 ITD 1 (Mumbai) (SB) Questions before Special bench 254
506 2012-08-10 Kotak Mahindra Capital Co. Ltd.
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Range 3(2)
[2012] 138 ITD 57 (Mumbai) (SB) Applicability of Sec 74(1) 74
507 2012-09-07 Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd.
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Gandhinagar Circle, Gandhinagar
[2012] 138 ITD 203 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Setting up of business 37(1)
508 2012-10-26 Vinod Kumar Jain
v.
Income-tax Officer-Ward-1(3), Jammu*
[2012] 140 ITD 1 (Amritsar) (SB) Refund of excise duty 4
509 2012-11-30 Saffire Garments
v.
Income-tax Officer, Ward 2, Gandhidham
[2013] 140 ITD 6 (Rajkot) (SB) Deduction u/s 10A 10A
510 2013-04-17 Gujarat Gas Financial Services Ltd.
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle – 4, Ahmedabad
[2013] 142 ITD 21 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) (SB) Set aside for determining the nature of lease 2, 28
511 2013-07-16 Biocon Ltd.
v.
Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (LTU), Bangalore
[2014] 144 ITD 21 (Bangalore – Trib.) (SB) Discount on ESOP 37
512 2013-09-06 Bharti Auto Products
v.
Commissioner of Income-tax-II, Rajkot
[2013] 145 ITD 1 (Rajkot – Trib.) (SB) (TRIB.) Liability of a seller for collection of tax at source u/s 206C 260C
513 2014-03-25 Alkaben B. Patel
v.
Income-tax Officer, Ward -14(2), Ahmedabad*
[2014] 148 ITD 31 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) (SB) Term – ‘month’ 54EC, General Clauses Act
514 2014-05-23 Nanubhai D. Desai
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle, Surat
[2014] 149 ITD 16 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) (SB) Powers of ITAT 254
515 2015-10-16 National Agricultural Co-Operative Marketing Federation of India Ltd.
v.
Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, Range-32, New Delhi National Agricultural Co-Operative Marketing Federation of India Ltd.
[2016] 156 ITD 11 (Delhi – Trib.) (SB) Year of claim of deduction 37(1)
516 2016-07-15 Instrumentarium Corporation Ltd vs. Assistant Director of Income-tax (International taxation) [2016] 179 TTJ (Kol)(SB) 665 [15-07-2016] Applicability of Chapter X – ALP adjustment possible – even if no income is reported 92 & 92C
517 2016-12-02 Neptune Developers & Construction (P.) Ltd., In re vs. [Income tax settlement commission] [2017] 79 taxmann.com 134 (ITSC – Mumbai) (SB) [02-12-2016] Admission of application to SetCom – if additional income disclosed in application exceeds threshold limits 245C
518 2017-01-20 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Company Circle I(2), Chennai vs. Bharat Overseas Bank Ltd. [2017] 81 taxmann.com 179 (Chennai – Trib.) (SB) [20-01-2017] Interest-tax collected – will not form part of chargeable interest 6 of Interest-tax Act, 1974
519 2017-02-14 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-16(2), Hyderabad vs. Progressive Constructions Ltd. [2018] 92 taxmann.com 104 (Hyderabad – Trib.) (SB) [14-02-2017] Construction of road on BOT basis – eligible for depreciation – no amortisation of construction costs

S/14A disallownace to be restricted to exempt income

32(1)(ii), 37(1), 14A
Circular 9 / 2014
520 2017-06-16 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 17 (1), New Delhi vs. Vireet Investment (P.) Ltd. [2017] 82 taxmann.com 415 (Delhi – Trib.) (SB) [16-06-2017] Book Profits – computation of disallowance u/s 14A

S/14A disallownace to be restricted to exempt income

115JB r.w.s 14A

14A r.w. Rule 8D

521 2017-09-26 Claris Life Sciences Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, (OSD), Ahmedabad [2017] 86 taxmann.com 56 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) (SB) [26-09-2017] Penalty payable when no self assessment tax paid on filing original return 221 r.w.s 140A
522 2018-04-30 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-4, Ahmedabad vs. Goldmine Shares and Finance (P.) Ltd. [2008] 113 ITD 209 (Ahmedabad – ITAT) (SB) Computation of deduction u/s. 80-IA, after deduction of notional b/f losses and depreciation of eligible business Section 80-IA of IT Act
523 2018-06-05 Nokia Networks OY vs. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax [2018] 194 TTJ (Del)(SB) 137 [05-06-2018] Permanent establishment – activities carried out are of preparatory and auxiliary nature Section 90, Art 5 of India-Finland DTAA
524 2018-06-13 Deepak Sales & Properties (P.) Ltd. vs. Additional Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 9(1), Mumbai [2018] 95 taxmann.com 166 (Mumbai) (SB) [13-06-2018] Penalty – accepting cash loans without proving necessity 269SS r.w.s 271D
525 2018-07-09 Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-2 (1), Hyderabad vs. Inventaa Industries (P.) Ltd. [2018] 95 taxmann.com 162 (Hyderabad – Trib.) (SB) [09-07-2018] Income from production and sale of Mushrooms is agricultural income 2(1A)
526 2018-07-19 CLC & Sons (P.) Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle- 3 (1), New Delhi [2018] 95 taxmann.com 219 (Delhi – Trib.) (SB) [19-07-2018] Depreciation available on genuine Goodwill 32
527 2018-10-09 Virudhunagar District Central Co-operative bank Ltd vs. Income Tax Officer [2018] 196 TTJ (Chennai)(SB) 921 [09-10-2018] Co-operative society carrying on banking business not liable to deduct TDS on interest paid 194A(3)
528 2018-12-26 Doshi Accounting services (P) Ltd vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2019] 202 TTJ (Ahd)(SB) 845 [26-12-2018] Applicability of Chapter X – Even if income is exempt under Section 10A – Arm’s Length Price to be determined 10A r.w.s. 92C
529 2019-02-25 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Cir. 6, Ahmedabad vs. Himanshu vs. Shah [2019] 104 taxmann.com 279 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) (SB) [25-02-2019] Deductions – Infrastructure undertakings (franchisee of telecom service provider) 80-IA(4)(ii)
530 2019-03-07 GTC Industries Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, CC-IX, Mumbai [2017] 80 taxmann.com 284 (Mumbai) (SB) [07-03-2019] Unexplained investments 69
531 2019-04-18 Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, B.K. Circle, palanpur vs. People’s Co.Op. Credit Society Ltd. [2019] 107 taxmann.com 53 (Ahmedabad – Trib.) (SB) [18-04-2019] Deductions – Income from Co-op. Soc – Relief 80P(2)(a)(i) / 80P(4)
532 2019-10-24 Doshi Accounting services (P) Ltd vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2019] 197 TTJ (Ahd)(SB) 273 [24-10-2019] Stay on recovery of outstanding demand extended as delay not due to assessee 254(2A)

Comments are closed.