-
India
represents the biggest democracy in the world. The Constitution of India is
the supreme law of the land. One of the most important provision of the
Constitution of India is Article 265, which provides that “no tax shall be
levied or collected except by authority of law”.
-
Since, 1991, India has
concentrated on development, liberalization process of law and procedure for
doing business in India, Scrapping of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act,
introduction of Foreign Exchange Management Act, Information Technology Act,
Right to Information Act, Money Laundering Act, Limited Liability Partnership
Act, Value Added Tax (VAT), uniform Stamp Act, are steps in the right
direction, to attract foreign investment. Dividend income is completely
exempt. Capital gains in respect of quoted shares of company which are held
for more than one year are also exempt from income-tax. Corporate Taxation
rate is only 35% which is considered as one of the lowest in the developing
countries. Political stability has added advantages for doing business in
India. Whichever the Government comes in to power, the liberalization process
and foreign policy remain unaffected. India is the only country which has set
up “National Knowledge Commission”. We have multi cultural, multi language
multi religious background which is truly secular.
-
India has one of the finest
judicial systems. India has a matured tax system and tax administration. The
cost of tax collection in India is only 0.67%, which can be considered as one
of the lowest in the world. Non Residents can approach the Authority for
Advance Rulings for Direct Taxes, as well as Indirect Taxes for determination
by the Authority in relation to a transaction which has been undertaken or a
proposed to be undertaken by a non resident applicant or a determination by
the Authority in relation to a transaction which has been undertaken or
proposed to be undertaken by a resident applicant with a non resident.
-
India is recognized as
emerging leader in the legal process outsourcing industry. This is mainly
because of talented English speaking lawyers, Chartered Accountants, computer
education, development of Technology and our legal system which follows the
British Tradition. The Apex court, High Courts, quasi-judicial Authorities,
the Tribunals, Tax administration, the proceedings are conducted and orders
are passed in English. The legal opinions and the Arbitration proceedings are
in English language.
-
At present the leadership of
India is with great visionaries, His Excellency Dr A.P.J Abdul Kalam as
President of India, Dr. Manmohan Singh as Prime Minister of India, Hon’ble Mr.
Justice Balakrishnan as Chief Justice of India and Mr. P. Chidambaram, a great
lawyer who studied at Harward University of USA as a Hon’ble Finance Minister
of India. One may not find anywhere in the world such a well read and great
visionaries are leading the nation. India is shining and it is the right
opportunity to visit and share partnership in the progress of the country,
which will benefit USA as well as India.
-
Considering the commercial
and legal advantages, we are of the well considered view that three is a great
scope and opportunity for India-USA legal and business partnership. On the
occasion of 2nd International Study Tour to USA, we have released our
publication titled “INDIA – USA - BUSINESS AND LEGAL PARTNERSHIP – STRATEGIES”
at Washington and New York. An attempt has been made in the said publication
to highlight the legal requirements of doing business in India.
-
I had the privilege of
associating with two International study tours organized by the All India
Federation of Tax Practitioners. During an interaction with the legal and
accountancy fraternity of USA, it is observed that the people at large of USA
consider the India as one of the emerging super powers of Asian continent. It
is heartening to note that President of USA George W. Bush has highest regard
and respect to Indian democracy and specially to our Hon’ble Prime Minister
Dr. Manmohan Singh. In the course of interaction with advisors to Government
of USA various Merchant Bankers, and Attorneys, we have been informed that
huge investments are likely to invested in India there are many cross border
transactions are likely to be held in the years to come. We find there is a
very positive approach for investing in India and this trend will continue for
at least for another two decades.
-
The main difference in
respect of legal practice in India and USA, is in India legal practitioners
cannot advertise whereas in USA we found huge advertisement hoardings of law
firms. In India profession is still considered as service whereas in USA it is
only business. We had an opportunity to visit the Supreme Court of USA. We
have been told less then hundred matters are pending for hearing and disposal.
We have been told only half an hour is given to the petitioner and another
half an hour to the respondent. The entire hearing will be over with in one
hour. Is it possible in our country to conclude the hearing within one hour?
It is a thought for debate?
-
When the investment from USA
increases, USA attorneys entrepreneurs do require correct advice from the tax
practitioners of India. Similarly when Indian entrepreneurs makes huge
investments at USA they do require correct advice from the USA lawyers. The
question to be asked by ourselves is, are we in a position to render legal
services which the USA lawyers desire from us. My answer will be no. As a tax
practitioners we are only dealing with taxation aspect of the matter, however
the investor from USA requires the advice in respect of FEMA, SEBI regulation
etc. Most of our practices are individual practice and we don’t have big set
up hence it may not be possible to render the required service. To render
services to big clients we have to become big. Many chartered accountants
firms have restructured their practice and became big to render all services,
under one roof. We have very few law firms and chartered accountancy firms
which are big and capable of handling all aspects of capital markets .
-
We have around 7,50,000
Lawyers and around 1,20,000 Chartered Accountants and good number of other
professionals. It is the time to debate and join hands with likeminded people
so that your firm can also be capable of giving advice to multinationals and
big assessees. There could be an arrangements and affiliation between Lawyers
and Chartered Accountants. According to me profession of law and accountancy
are complimentary to each other and if they join together it will immensely
benefit to both the profession.
-
When we visit countries
we learn the culture, business environment, work culture, ethics etc., One who
desire to develop International Tax practice has to visit various countries,
have to interact with the professionals and gain knowledge of International
emerging issues, no doubt the scope is very wide, but how many will able to
take advantages of the development of the economy?
Dr. K. SHIVARAM
Editor-in-chief |